“It’s a violation of contract. It’s allowing the status quo to continue and doing so at the expense of an industry that is just now scaling up to size,” said Denise Bode, CEO of the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA), regarding Bonneville Power Administration’s (BPA’s) decision to temporarily limit output from non-hydropower resources.
Bode addressed BPA’s actions during a press conference at the Windpower 2011 Conference and Exhibition in Anaheim, Calif. on May 23. High seasonal river flows and hydroelectric generation in the Pacific Northwest led BPA to issue an interim decision on May 13 to address what it called a “potentially imminent need” to temporarily limit wind generation and other sources.
“We’ve been begging Bonneville to take action and move forward,” Bode said. “Now when they’re in trouble, they shut down the only other renewable sector besides hydro and they let the coal keep burning.”
BPA, however, says it is limiting the output of all non-hydroelectric energy, including fossil-fuel and other thermal generation and wind energy, according to a BPA press release. BPA says the action was required to protect salmon and steelhead, maintain the reliability of the power grid and avoid shifting costs to BPA’s customers.
Governor Brian Schweitzer of Montana, who also participated in the press conference, said that BPA has been short-sided regarding its decision to limit wind power. “What they don’t have is transmission capacity to get the electricity to market. If we don’t move now, five and ten years from now, it’s going to be much greater as we come out of this recession.”
While BPA is under AWEA’s scrutiny, the state of California is receiving AWEA’s high praises for the continued success of its goal to have 33 percent of its electric generation from renewable sources by 2020. Bode said that since Senate Bill 2X was signed into law, interest in California wind portfolios has exploded.
“It’s like the floodgates have opened,” Bode said.
The wind industry now supports 15 wind-related manufacturing facilities in California. In addition, 4,000 to 5,000 permanent workers help maintain and operate the 3,177 MW of wind power already online in California, equaling 3 to 5 percent of the state’s generation, depending on peaking needs.
Bode also applauded the role that wind energy played during the March earthquake and tsunami in Japan. None of the wind turbines in Japan were impacted by the disasters, Bode said, evidence to the quality of the product. However, wind generation was limited at times due to transmission issues.
“Japan’s story really told the story for a need for diversification. Renewable resources should be a part of every portfolio.”
The Up In The Air blog discusses what's floating around concerning EPA emissions rules, and what the power industry is doing to prepare for regulations. You'll also find discussions about Smart Grid and other developments pertinent to the power industry.
Monday, May 23, 2011
Thursday, May 19, 2011
Would you like to add solar to your order?
Solar energy augmentation projects are being cooked up world over. Traditional coal and natural gas-fired plants are adding solar to their plants -- both as a way to generate more power, but perhaps also as a way to create a more positive public image.
On April 13, Areva was awarded a contract to install a solar thermal addition to CS Energy’s coal-fired Kogan Creek power station in Queensland, Australia. Adding solar energy to the Kogan Creek power station will increase its output by up to 44 MW in peak solar conditions to the current 750 MW.
Solar boosts like these are taking place in the U.S. as well. My colleague Brian Wheeler wrote a story for our May issue of Power Engineering on Florida Power & Light’s Martin Next Generation Solar Energy Center located near Indiantown, Fla., which started operations in December 2010. Thousands of parabolic mirrors concentrate the sun’s thermal energy onto heat collection elements that contain a heat transfer fluid called Dowtherm A. The fluid heats up and is pumped through heat exchangers, producing steam from feed water supplied by the existing plant. The steam is sent to existing Nooter-Erikson combined-cycle heat recovery steam generators. It is expected that 100 additional megawatts with be generated through this steam process, adding to the pre-existing 1,150 MW of generation.
Various studies are taking place to increase the effectiveness of solar-augmented coal plants, such as at Tri-State’s 245 MW Escalante Station in Prewitt, N.M. With a goal of increasing power plant efficiency while incorporating renewable technologies, Tri-State entered into an agreement with the Electric Power Research Institute in 2009 to host the case study. The ongoing project attempts to provide a conceptual design study, analyze options to retrofit the existing power plant and identify new plant design options.
Here are a few reasons why adding solar to an existing facility just makes sense:
1. Cooling. In the case of the Martin Next Generation Solar Energy Center and other CSP projects, the water needed for cooling is already available via feed water from the existing plant.
2. Transmission. Existing power plants are already connected to the grid, preventing problems with access to transmission that new concentrated solar power (CSP) plants often face.
3. Financials. Advocates of solar augmentation also argue that the technique achieves higher thermal to electric conversion efficiency and potentially lower costs compared to stand-alone solar facilities. Also, the addition of a solar component allows access to renewable energy credit markets and other fiscal incentives for clean energy.
For more on traditional power plants that have added solar to their “generation menu,” check out this story that ran in the November 2010 Power Engineering. Order up!
On April 13, Areva was awarded a contract to install a solar thermal addition to CS Energy’s coal-fired Kogan Creek power station in Queensland, Australia. Adding solar energy to the Kogan Creek power station will increase its output by up to 44 MW in peak solar conditions to the current 750 MW.
Solar boosts like these are taking place in the U.S. as well. My colleague Brian Wheeler wrote a story for our May issue of Power Engineering on Florida Power & Light’s Martin Next Generation Solar Energy Center located near Indiantown, Fla., which started operations in December 2010. Thousands of parabolic mirrors concentrate the sun’s thermal energy onto heat collection elements that contain a heat transfer fluid called Dowtherm A. The fluid heats up and is pumped through heat exchangers, producing steam from feed water supplied by the existing plant. The steam is sent to existing Nooter-Erikson combined-cycle heat recovery steam generators. It is expected that 100 additional megawatts with be generated through this steam process, adding to the pre-existing 1,150 MW of generation.
Various studies are taking place to increase the effectiveness of solar-augmented coal plants, such as at Tri-State’s 245 MW Escalante Station in Prewitt, N.M. With a goal of increasing power plant efficiency while incorporating renewable technologies, Tri-State entered into an agreement with the Electric Power Research Institute in 2009 to host the case study. The ongoing project attempts to provide a conceptual design study, analyze options to retrofit the existing power plant and identify new plant design options.
Here are a few reasons why adding solar to an existing facility just makes sense:
1. Cooling. In the case of the Martin Next Generation Solar Energy Center and other CSP projects, the water needed for cooling is already available via feed water from the existing plant.
2. Transmission. Existing power plants are already connected to the grid, preventing problems with access to transmission that new concentrated solar power (CSP) plants often face.
3. Financials. Advocates of solar augmentation also argue that the technique achieves higher thermal to electric conversion efficiency and potentially lower costs compared to stand-alone solar facilities. Also, the addition of a solar component allows access to renewable energy credit markets and other fiscal incentives for clean energy.
For more on traditional power plants that have added solar to their “generation menu,” check out this story that ran in the November 2010 Power Engineering. Order up!
Friday, April 15, 2011
EPA's hint to coal generators (shhh...it's natural gas!)
As a newlywed 10 months into marriage, I’m still learning that dropping hints is not always the strongest form of communication. I might mention to my husband all week long things like, “Doesn’t queso from such-and-such restaurant sound good?” Then the weekend rolls around, and he still innocently asks, “What kind of restaurant should we try?” Sometimes hints aren’t picked up on. Or even if they are, they aren’t always acted upon. But still, it's often more comfortable, less abrasive to use hints in place of direct communication. It seems to me that the Environmental Protection Agency is a hint-dropper. The Administration doesn’t come out and force conversions from coal to natural gas or renewables. But through nagging mechanisms even more powerful than those possessed by the cast of Desperate Housewives, the EPA can make life tough on coal-fired generators. On April 14, I attended an EPA hearing in Tulsa, Okla. concerning an ongoing debate over three coal-fired plants that are not under compliance of EPA’s Clean Air Visibility Rule. The plants are Oklahoma Gas and Electric (OG&E) Company’s Muskogee and Sooner Stations, and AEP-Public Service Company of Oklahoma’s Red Rock Station. According to the rule, the stations must achieve EPA’s emission limit for SO2 – 0.15 lb/mmBtu, or 95 percent removal. OG&E said it would cost about $10,000 per ton to reduce SO2 emissions to those levels through the use of scrubber technology at its two plants. The Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality (ODEQ) has submitted a State Implementation Plan (SIP), recommending Best Available Retrofit Technology (BART) switches for the plants. However, the EPA identified the SIP as one that “does not meet one or more of the required elements.” Why doesn’t it meet the requirements? Steve Thompson, executive director of ODEQ, said the BART alternative in the SIP “reduces SO2 emissions more than the primary requirements in EPA’s Federal Implementation Plan.” So what about that is unacceptable to the EPA? Coal is still being burned. Visibility could still be affected to some degree in federal wildlife areas – the heart of the issue. EPA states that “switches to natural gas are an acceptable method,” as a spokesperson from Oklahoma natural gas producer Chesapeake Energy pointed out at the hearing. Oklahoma has an abundant supply of natural gas. Larry Nichols, CEO of Devon Energy, told me during a March interview that the company’s work in the Cana shale in western Oklahoma which has already netted 11 trillion cubic feet – larger than Devon’s four discoveries in the Gulf of Mexico. So a shortage of a natural gas supply would be close to impossible if these power companies were to do a partial or total switch. It’s not just these Oklahoma coal plants that will soon be replaced by natural gas or another form of “cleaner” energy. On April 14, Tennessee Valley Authority announced the retirement of 18 coal-fired units. In many cases, it’s easier to retire a plant than to retrofit it, especially older plants. Barney Racine, software development manger for the environmental solutions group of Honeywell Process Solutions, said the EPA’s focus is not so much on SO2 control, but rather a complete retreat from coal. “They’re not necessarily driving legislation from the emissions monitoring standpoint, but from the incentive side – the cost to burn coal vs. natural gas.” Some coal will undoubtedly remain in the generation mix in the coming decades, but EPA will continue to drop hints that other forms of generation are preferable. While natural gas prices are low, many coal-fired generators will, reluctantly or not, make the switch. EPA’s hint will be taken with a grain of salt, or perhaps in some cases, enforced. And hopefully through tactful hints rather than a means of force even more powerful than the EPA's, I’ll get my chips and queso this weekend.
Labels:
AEP,
Chesapeake,
coal-fired power plants,
Devon Energy,
EPA Clean Air Visibility,
natural gas power plants,
Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality,
Oklahoma Gas and Electric,
PSO
Wednesday, April 13, 2011
What stands in the way of California’s 33 percent renewables goal?
On April 12, California Governor Jerry Brown signed Senate Bill 2X into law, requiring that 33 percent of the state’s electric generation come from renewable sources by 2020.
Under S.B. 2X, all load-serving entities must meet a 20 percent renewables target by Dec. 31, 2013, a 25 percent target by the end of 2016, and achieve the 33 percent criterion by the end of 2020.
S.B. 2X applies to all electricity retailers in the state – investor-owned utilities, municipal utilities and independent sellers. The current 20 percent renewable energy requirement applies only to investor-owned utilities and independent power producers.
One municipal utility, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, has already reached the 2013 goal of generating 20 percent of its power from renewables. Smaller municipal utilities like Glendale, Anaheim, Pasadena and Burbank, are behind at this stage in terms of how much renewable power they have in their portfolios, said Dario Frommer, partner at Mayer Brown law firm.
Most investor-owned utilities in California are hovering just under 20 percent renewables now. While it may seem that investor-owned utilities are close to meeting the 2013 goal, many of these projects are in litigation over siting issues and may not be completed in time to meet the 2013 target, Frommer said.
“It’s incumbent on the political leaders to address the siting issues that are creating problems for financing,” Frommer said. “Those issues are an impediment to realizing the 33 percent goal.”
Concerns over siting issues and financing may abound, but S.B. 2X is expected to bring stronger solar and wind markets to the state. During the signing ceremony, U.S. Energy Secretary Steven Chu said he sees the measure as a model for other states. Chu also announced a tentative commitment of $1.2 billion in loan guarantees for a 250 MW solar energy project in San Luis Obispo County.
Jenya Meydbray, CEO of Berkeley-based PV Evolution Labs, said S.B. 2X creates long-term sustainability in the California solar market. “The lack of long-term policy foresight has been one big challenge for solar manufacturers in North America. This new law solidifies California’s dedication to developing a sustainable solar market, which will in turn enhance solar’s viability as a job-creating industry.”
Solar won’t be the only renewable energy form to brighten in the Golden State. According to the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) Annual Market Report for 2010, California came in third for the most wind capacity installed in 2010, totaling 3,177 MW of total capacity. Wind growth in California is expected to continue with the implementation of S.B. 2X, said Denise Bode, CEO of AWEA.
“California understands the direct link between sound policy and renewable energy’s multiple benefits … California has already seen the jobs and economic development that follow when the right policies are put in place to create a stable business and investment environment,” Bode said.
Since it was passed during a special legislative session, S.B. 2X is not expected to take effect until early July.
Under S.B. 2X, all load-serving entities must meet a 20 percent renewables target by Dec. 31, 2013, a 25 percent target by the end of 2016, and achieve the 33 percent criterion by the end of 2020.
S.B. 2X applies to all electricity retailers in the state – investor-owned utilities, municipal utilities and independent sellers. The current 20 percent renewable energy requirement applies only to investor-owned utilities and independent power producers.
One municipal utility, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, has already reached the 2013 goal of generating 20 percent of its power from renewables. Smaller municipal utilities like Glendale, Anaheim, Pasadena and Burbank, are behind at this stage in terms of how much renewable power they have in their portfolios, said Dario Frommer, partner at Mayer Brown law firm.
Most investor-owned utilities in California are hovering just under 20 percent renewables now. While it may seem that investor-owned utilities are close to meeting the 2013 goal, many of these projects are in litigation over siting issues and may not be completed in time to meet the 2013 target, Frommer said.
“It’s incumbent on the political leaders to address the siting issues that are creating problems for financing,” Frommer said. “Those issues are an impediment to realizing the 33 percent goal.”
Concerns over siting issues and financing may abound, but S.B. 2X is expected to bring stronger solar and wind markets to the state. During the signing ceremony, U.S. Energy Secretary Steven Chu said he sees the measure as a model for other states. Chu also announced a tentative commitment of $1.2 billion in loan guarantees for a 250 MW solar energy project in San Luis Obispo County.
Jenya Meydbray, CEO of Berkeley-based PV Evolution Labs, said S.B. 2X creates long-term sustainability in the California solar market. “The lack of long-term policy foresight has been one big challenge for solar manufacturers in North America. This new law solidifies California’s dedication to developing a sustainable solar market, which will in turn enhance solar’s viability as a job-creating industry.”
Solar won’t be the only renewable energy form to brighten in the Golden State. According to the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) Annual Market Report for 2010, California came in third for the most wind capacity installed in 2010, totaling 3,177 MW of total capacity. Wind growth in California is expected to continue with the implementation of S.B. 2X, said Denise Bode, CEO of AWEA.
“California understands the direct link between sound policy and renewable energy’s multiple benefits … California has already seen the jobs and economic development that follow when the right policies are put in place to create a stable business and investment environment,” Bode said.
Since it was passed during a special legislative session, S.B. 2X is not expected to take effect until early July.
Monday, April 4, 2011
Filling the nuclear development void
As Japan and the world pick up the pieces leftover from Fukushima, the looming question is: What form(s) of energy will fill the nuclear void? Some countries, including China and Germany, have already decided to phase out nuclear developments that were underway, looking to solar or energy imports instead.
Our online audience expressed their opinions on how the nuclear development void could be filled in an online poll last week. The results show that 49 percent of poll participants expect natural gas to see the biggest gain if nuclear is suspended or delayed. That’s no surprise, with the current low prices of natural gas and the development of numerous shale gas plays in the U.S. and abroad.
A few days after the Fukushima disaster, I conducted the annual Executive Gas roundtable, which will appear in the May issue of Power Engineering magazine. Five leaders from the gas industry shared their thoughts on the natural gas industry, as well as impacts that Fukushima may have on the U.S. power industry.
John Adams, senior vice president of Power Operations at Calpine, pointed out that the predicted Nuclear Renaissance included 34 nuclear plants being licensed to go forward in the U.S. Yet of those 34, only “a handful looked like they were going to make it or were proceeding on a fast, timely basis.” Even before Fukushima, the Nuclear Renaissance was panning out to be more like a tiny ripple in the energy pond.
“Now we have this tragedy on top of it, which will actually slow it further,” Adams said.
Larry Nichols, CEO of gas exploration and production company Devon Energy, said the Japan tragedy is opening up legislators’ eyes to lower risk forms of energy.
“The nuclear problems in Japan will focus the minds of both the public and policy-makers on why we would provide loan guarantees of $38 billion for new nuclear plants. All the while we have such an abundant, cheap and clean resource like natural gas, which comes with minimal risk,” Nichols said.
Confirmations of those statements are now frequently popping up. A recent study from the Energy Information Administration found that the U.S. has twice the amount of projected recoverable natural gas (827 Tcf) than previously thought.
“Natural gas will take a much more dominant role as we go forward, moving from 20 percent to 40 percent over the next 25 years,” said Ed Walsh, executive vice president for Black & Veatch’s global energy business.
All right, enough about natural gas already. Solar is expected to be another big filler if nuclear growth in the U.S. slows down. Solar growth continues to grow in California, where on March 30 The California Assembly approved a bill that gives utilities until 2020 to have 33 percent of their generation sources come from renewable energy. New Jersey continues to make strides in solar growth as well. According to an April 4 speech by Rhone Resch, president of the Solar Energy Industries Association, the New Jersey solar market grew by 139 percent in 2010 and more than 100 MW was installed.
It is likely that nuclear development in the U.S. will not continue quite as was planned. However, as of March 15, President Barack Obama said that regulators should continue with the approval of construction licenses for new nuclear power plants despite Japan's nuclear crisis.
If a nuclear development slow or halt does occur, it’s likely that all forms of energy will work to fill the void. If natural gas prices reach a place of stability, a large portion of the nuclear development void will likely be filled by gas. Solar will also have its role, as well as hydro, wind, geothermal and biomass. Coal may even play a filler role through the use of supercritical and ultra-supercritical technologies could reduce carbon emissions and boost efficiencies, as well as IGCC plants.
Wednesday, March 9, 2011
Time for a Philosophy Shift
The Renewable Energy World Conference & Expo North America kicked off on March 8 with a unique perspective of the condition of the U.S. electric grid presented by Kurt Yeager, executive director of the Galvin Electric Institute and former president and CEO of the Electric Power Research Institute. Yeager stressed during his keynote address that electricity is at a point technologically “where we can reinvent Thomas Edison.” Much of that revitalization, Yeager said, will come through the continual development of a smarter grid.
While Smart Grid has a tendency to tack on a number of different name badges, Yeager defined it in three ways: Moving from analog to an electronically-monitored power system, a two-way consumer services gateway, and the reintroduction of direct current (DC)/microgrids.
In order for Smart Grid to work, electricity providers must develop a user-centric view, Yeager said.
“Smart Grid is a transactive network. The user becomes a partner, not a prisoner of the network.”
A smarter grid is also essential to grid reliability. Yeager presented a few astonishing numbers associated with grid reliability. The average consumer in the U.S. is without power four hours each year. That may seem like a drop in the bucket, but not in comparison to Japan, where consumers are without power seven minutes a year, and Singapore, where the average citizen would hardly notice the average seven electricity-deprived seconds a year.
Yeager noted that President Barack Obama’s goal to achieve 80 percent clean energy by 2035 is doable, but “we can’t do it without fundamentally changing the rules.” The principle shift, he said, needs to occur with smart grid developments. Yeager’s recommendations for change include providing consumers with a choice of access to real-time electricity prices, holding utilities publicly accountable to specific system performance standards, and expanding net metering to include physical aggregation and carbon portfolio standards.
A future in which customer-specific data belongs to the customer should be the electric future of America, Yeager said. If an individual has control over every other area of his or her personal life (bank account, stocks, cell phone bill) through technology devices galore, it should be no different with an individual’s electricity usage. The road to a smarter grid starts with a perspective shift from the electric industry, rather than following a lengthy to-do list. Thinking beyond what has already been done will be necessary if the electric industry is going to “reinvent Edison.”
While Smart Grid has a tendency to tack on a number of different name badges, Yeager defined it in three ways: Moving from analog to an electronically-monitored power system, a two-way consumer services gateway, and the reintroduction of direct current (DC)/microgrids.
In order for Smart Grid to work, electricity providers must develop a user-centric view, Yeager said.
“Smart Grid is a transactive network. The user becomes a partner, not a prisoner of the network.”
A smarter grid is also essential to grid reliability. Yeager presented a few astonishing numbers associated with grid reliability. The average consumer in the U.S. is without power four hours each year. That may seem like a drop in the bucket, but not in comparison to Japan, where consumers are without power seven minutes a year, and Singapore, where the average citizen would hardly notice the average seven electricity-deprived seconds a year.
Yeager noted that President Barack Obama’s goal to achieve 80 percent clean energy by 2035 is doable, but “we can’t do it without fundamentally changing the rules.” The principle shift, he said, needs to occur with smart grid developments. Yeager’s recommendations for change include providing consumers with a choice of access to real-time electricity prices, holding utilities publicly accountable to specific system performance standards, and expanding net metering to include physical aggregation and carbon portfolio standards.
A future in which customer-specific data belongs to the customer should be the electric future of America, Yeager said. If an individual has control over every other area of his or her personal life (bank account, stocks, cell phone bill) through technology devices galore, it should be no different with an individual’s electricity usage. The road to a smarter grid starts with a perspective shift from the electric industry, rather than following a lengthy to-do list. Thinking beyond what has already been done will be necessary if the electric industry is going to “reinvent Edison.”
Thursday, March 3, 2011
EPA’s Delay in GHG Reporting
On March 1, EPA announced an extension of the deadline to begin reporting greenhouse gases, which was slated to begin on March 31. A new deadline has not been announced, but the reason behind the delay will be the determining factor in how long the extension lasts.
Like most modern technology, EPA’s online reporting system, Electronic Greenhouse Gas Reporting Tool (e-GGRT), has not proven itself to be 100 percent e-GRRRREAT. According to Lisa Jaegar, associate at Bracewell & Giuliani LLP, e-GGRT was not available during some periods leading up to the Jan. 30, 2011 deadline to submit the requisite Certificate of Representation. Now, delays continue as the “Geek Squad” at EPA tries to sort out the technical difficulties (no, they aren’t outsourcing to Best Buy, but it might not be a bad idea).
“The reason the deadline has been changed is that EPA is continuing to test the system,” said Liz Williamson, associate at Winston & Strawn LLP. “We’re anticipating that it will probably be this summer when the first reporting requirement will be under e-GGRT.”
As a resource to GHG-reporting entities, EPA has posted a list of Frequently Asked Questions on its web site. Additionally, EPA is offering a number of training sessions to assist with learning e-GGRT and the rulemaking (by the way, the next scheduled training session is March 9).
While the extension was welcomed, it offers only a partial relief to reporting entities. Many companies have already sought technical clarifications from EPA to ensure they are monitoring or calculating emissions appropriately, Jaegar said. One of the main challenges to reporting GHGs is not the CO2 component of the reporting, but the reporting of the other five GHGs involved in the rulemaking: methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs), and sulfur hexafluoride (SF6).
“The CO2 is a little more straightforward because we’ve been collecting this data for a long time. But for the other five GHGs, it’s much more of a chore to collect the baseline data,” said Jay Holloway, associate with Winston & Strawn LLP.
In the end, it’s likely that every state except Texas (and possibly Wyoming) will enter GHG data under an EPA-approved state plan when the new deadline comes around. But for companies calculating and entering GHG data, this is just another collision in the “train-wreck” of regulations the industry is encountering. For now, however, the GHG train has slowed a bit, and companies may have a chance to gain a better understanding of what is expected.
Like most modern technology, EPA’s online reporting system, Electronic Greenhouse Gas Reporting Tool (e-GGRT), has not proven itself to be 100 percent e-GRRRREAT. According to Lisa Jaegar, associate at Bracewell & Giuliani LLP, e-GGRT was not available during some periods leading up to the Jan. 30, 2011 deadline to submit the requisite Certificate of Representation. Now, delays continue as the “Geek Squad” at EPA tries to sort out the technical difficulties (no, they aren’t outsourcing to Best Buy, but it might not be a bad idea).
“The reason the deadline has been changed is that EPA is continuing to test the system,” said Liz Williamson, associate at Winston & Strawn LLP. “We’re anticipating that it will probably be this summer when the first reporting requirement will be under e-GGRT.”
As a resource to GHG-reporting entities, EPA has posted a list of Frequently Asked Questions on its web site. Additionally, EPA is offering a number of training sessions to assist with learning e-GGRT and the rulemaking (by the way, the next scheduled training session is March 9).
While the extension was welcomed, it offers only a partial relief to reporting entities. Many companies have already sought technical clarifications from EPA to ensure they are monitoring or calculating emissions appropriately, Jaegar said. One of the main challenges to reporting GHGs is not the CO2 component of the reporting, but the reporting of the other five GHGs involved in the rulemaking: methane (CH4), nitrous oxide (N2O), hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), perfluorocarbons (PFCs), and sulfur hexafluoride (SF6).
“The CO2 is a little more straightforward because we’ve been collecting this data for a long time. But for the other five GHGs, it’s much more of a chore to collect the baseline data,” said Jay Holloway, associate with Winston & Strawn LLP.
In the end, it’s likely that every state except Texas (and possibly Wyoming) will enter GHG data under an EPA-approved state plan when the new deadline comes around. But for companies calculating and entering GHG data, this is just another collision in the “train-wreck” of regulations the industry is encountering. For now, however, the GHG train has slowed a bit, and companies may have a chance to gain a better understanding of what is expected.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)