Showing posts with label AEP. Show all posts
Showing posts with label AEP. Show all posts

Friday, April 15, 2011

EPA's hint to coal generators (shhh...it's natural gas!)

As a newlywed 10 months into marriage, I’m still learning that dropping hints is not always the strongest form of communication. I might mention to my husband all week long things like, “Doesn’t queso from such-and-such restaurant sound good?” Then the weekend rolls around, and he still innocently asks, “What kind of restaurant should we try?”

Sometimes hints aren’t picked up on. Or even if they are, they aren’t always acted upon. But still, it's often more comfortable, less abrasive to use hints in place of direct communication.

It seems to me that the Environmental Protection Agency is a hint-dropper. The Administration doesn’t come out and force conversions from coal to natural gas or renewables. But through nagging mechanisms even more powerful than those possessed by the cast of Desperate Housewives, the EPA can make life tough on coal-fired generators.

On April 14, I attended an EPA hearing in Tulsa, Okla. concerning an ongoing debate over three coal-fired plants that are not under compliance of EPA’s Clean Air Visibility Rule. The plants are Oklahoma Gas and Electric (OG&E) Company’s Muskogee and Sooner Stations, and AEP-Public Service Company of Oklahoma’s Red Rock Station. According to the rule, the stations must achieve EPA’s emission limit for SO2 – 0.15 lb/mmBtu, or 95 percent removal. OG&E said it would cost about $10,000 per ton to reduce SO2 emissions to those levels through the use of scrubber technology at its two plants.

The Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality (ODEQ) has submitted a State Implementation Plan (SIP), recommending Best Available Retrofit Technology (BART) switches for the plants. However, the EPA identified the SIP as one that “does not meet one or more of the required elements.”

Why doesn’t it meet the requirements? Steve Thompson, executive director of ODEQ, said the BART alternative in the SIP “reduces SO2 emissions more than the primary requirements in EPA’s Federal Implementation Plan.”

So what about that is unacceptable to the EPA?

Coal is still being burned. Visibility could still be affected to some degree in federal wildlife areas – the heart of the issue.

EPA states that “switches to natural gas are an acceptable method,” as a spokesperson from Oklahoma natural gas producer Chesapeake Energy pointed out at the hearing.

Oklahoma has an abundant supply of natural gas. Larry Nichols, CEO of Devon Energy, told me during a March interview that the company’s work in the Cana shale in western Oklahoma which has already netted 11 trillion cubic feet – larger than Devon’s four discoveries in the Gulf of Mexico. So a shortage of a natural gas supply would be close to impossible if these power companies were to do a partial or total switch.

It’s not just these Oklahoma coal plants that will soon be replaced by natural gas or another form of “cleaner” energy. On April 14, Tennessee Valley Authority announced the retirement of 18 coal-fired units. In many cases, it’s easier to retire a plant than to retrofit it, especially older plants.

Barney Racine, software development manger for the environmental solutions group of Honeywell Process Solutions, said the EPA’s focus is not so much on SO2 control, but rather a complete retreat from coal. “They’re not necessarily driving legislation from the emissions monitoring standpoint, but from the incentive side – the cost to burn coal vs. natural gas.”

Some coal will undoubtedly remain in the generation mix in the coming decades, but EPA will continue to drop hints that other forms of generation are preferable. While natural gas prices are low, many coal-fired generators will, reluctantly or not, make the switch. EPA’s hint will be taken with a grain of salt, or perhaps in some cases, enforced.

And hopefully through tactful hints rather than a means of force even more powerful than the EPA's, I’ll get my chips and queso this weekend.

Tuesday, December 14, 2010

POWER-GEN International keynote address: Regaining industry-wide momentum

Conference and exhibition attendees streamed into the Valencia Ballroom of the Orlando Convention Center the morning of Dec. 14 for the kickoff session of POWER-GEN International 2010. The keynote address, “Regaining Momentum,” included presentations and a Q&A session with Dr. Terry Michalske, director of the Savannah River National Laboratory, Dr. RenĂ© Umlauft, CEO of the renewable energy division for Siemens AG, Susan Tomasky, president of AEP Transmission, and David Fiorelli, president and CEO for the business development group at Tenaska.

With developing countries expected to drive energy demand and global carbon emissions in the upcoming decades, Michalske said nuclear must play a strong role in reducing emissions by 2050. An increasing portion of nuclear growth will be in the development of small modular reactors (SMRs), he said.

“Small modular reactors could be game-changing technology to take us to the new energy future,” Michalske said, asserting the benefits of SMRs: high efficiency, the ability to be monitored remotely, and a long fuel lifetime (up to 30 years).

One of the most important challenges in nuclear is getting through the regulatory approval for a carbon legislation, Michalske said. “It will take a concerted effort between the industry and government in order to move this forward.”

However, in 2009, 3 percent of worldwide generation came from renewable energy. That number is expected to rise to 17 percent by 2030, Siemens AG’s Umlauft said, with much of the increase coming from India and China. Half of renewable growth will come from wind power, 31 percent from solar, 15 percent from biomass, and 4 percent from geothermal and other sources, he said.

Umlauft said manufacturing wind turbines at a national level will create jobs and drive costs down, leading to the proposed jump in wind generation. A 20 to 30 percent reduction of onshore wind costs is expected in the next few years as a result of manufacturing changes.

While storage is often viewed as the “holy grail” of renewable energy development, Umlauft said other tools should be developed first. These tools include the creation of longer transmission lines, prediction methods for wind and solar and Smart Grid innovations.

Speaking on the need for transmission to help power generation companies regain a foothold in the economy, Tomasky of AEP Transmission said in her opening statements, “We are beginning to see the market of transmission as a business for building transmission.”

Transmission needs to be an important issue because of dramatic shifts in the generation profile that have taken place, the necessity to integrate electrically isolated large scale renewables, and the emissions control regulations that will require the retrofitting or retirement of some coal-fired plants, she said.

“Our present system is … ill-equipped to integrate large-scale renewable resources,” Tomasky said. “Renewable resources are often located in areas of the country where there is little or no transmission infrastructure.”

She said that wind generation presents a “chicken and egg issue”: Generators are hesitant to put transmission in place, and transmission is not often pursued until the generation is committed.

“Getting wind into the system requires a much more robust transmission system.”

Tomasky also said that while incentives for renewables may be uncertain, incentives for new technologies are most likely to survive. “Anything we can do to demonstrate to FERC that we’re building a smarter grid is an opportunity for return.”

Fiorelli spoke on the need for developing cleaner coal. Though the long-term effects of shale gas on gas prices are still unknown, it appears that prices and volatility of natural gas will continue to fall, he said. When combined with regulations concerns like the transport rule and rules for mercury, hazardous air pollutants and CO2, producers should begin looking towards clean coal options before being met with the possibility of detrimental outcomes for coal plants.

Tenaska has recently developed two integrated gas combined cycle (IGCC) plants, the Taylorville Energy Center in Taylorville, Ill., and the Trailblazer Energy Center, a PC plant with Fluor carbon capture technology to be located in west Texas.

During the Q&A session, Tenaska’s Fiorelli said productivity in policy-making seems to slow with every new election. “We need people to establish policy, write rules and regulations, and then get out of the way,” Fiorelli said.

Under greenhouse gas regulations, Fiorelli said, first movers could receive bonus allowances to support project economics even under low or moderate carbon price scenarios, adding to the incentives to move toward clean coal.