Showing posts with label California renewable energy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label California renewable energy. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 13, 2011

What stands in the way of California’s 33 percent renewables goal?

On April 12, California Governor Jerry Brown signed Senate Bill 2X into law, requiring that 33 percent of the state’s electric generation come from renewable sources by 2020.

Under S.B. 2X, all load-serving entities must meet a 20 percent renewables target by Dec. 31, 2013, a 25 percent target by the end of 2016, and achieve the 33 percent criterion by the end of 2020.

S.B. 2X applies to all electricity retailers in the state – investor-owned utilities, municipal utilities and independent sellers. The current 20 percent renewable energy requirement applies only to investor-owned utilities and independent power producers.

One municipal utility, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, has already reached the 2013 goal of generating 20 percent of its power from renewables. Smaller municipal utilities like Glendale, Anaheim, Pasadena and Burbank, are behind at this stage in terms of how much renewable power they have in their portfolios, said Dario Frommer, partner at Mayer Brown law firm.

Most investor-owned utilities in California are hovering just under 20 percent renewables now. While it may seem that investor-owned utilities are close to meeting the 2013 goal, many of these projects are in litigation over siting issues and may not be completed in time to meet the 2013 target, Frommer said.

“It’s incumbent on the political leaders to address the siting issues that are creating problems for financing,” Frommer said. “Those issues are an impediment to realizing the 33 percent goal.”

Concerns over siting issues and financing may abound, but S.B. 2X is expected to bring stronger solar and wind markets to the state. During the signing ceremony, U.S. Energy Secretary Steven Chu said he sees the measure as a model for other states. Chu also announced a tentative commitment of $1.2 billion in loan guarantees for a 250 MW solar energy project in San Luis Obispo County.

Jenya Meydbray, CEO of Berkeley-based PV Evolution Labs, said S.B. 2X creates long-term sustainability in the California solar market. “The lack of long-term policy foresight has been one big challenge for solar manufacturers in North America. This new law solidifies California’s dedication to developing a sustainable solar market, which will in turn enhance solar’s viability as a job-creating industry.”

Solar won’t be the only renewable energy form to brighten in the Golden State. According to the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA) Annual Market Report for 2010, California came in third for the most wind capacity installed in 2010, totaling 3,177 MW of total capacity. Wind growth in California is expected to continue with the implementation of S.B. 2X, said Denise Bode, CEO of AWEA.

“California understands the direct link between sound policy and renewable energy’s multiple benefits … California has already seen the jobs and economic development that follow when the right policies are put in place to create a stable business and investment environment,” Bode said.

Since it was passed during a special legislative session, S.B. 2X is not expected to take effect until early July.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Californians Mark the Ballot for Renewable Energy: The Defeat of Proposition 23

In what is being considered the largest public vote on clean energy policy in U.S. history, Proposition 23 was defeated yesterday by approximately 60 percent of California voters. Proponents of climate law AB 32, which would have been suspended if Proposition 23 had passed, are saying this sends a clear message to state and federal leaders that even during a major economic downtown in a state with one of the nation’s highest unemployment rates, voters want a clean energy future.

Wade Crowfoot, West Coast political director for the Environmental Defense Fund, said the defeat of Proposition 23 is an undeniable win for renewable energy. “Californians actually recognize that the clean energy economy is expanding around them. Voters didn’t buy scare tactics that somehow clean energy costs jobs.”

Opposition to Proposition 23 came from beyond the realm of typical clean energy supporters, garnering support from Republicans, including California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and former U.S. Secretary of State George Shultz, and Democrats, including President Barack Obama, California Senator Barbara Boxer and Attorney General Jerry Brown. Hundreds of businesses rallied to oppose the proposition, from Fortune 500 companies to small businesses, including the organization Small Business California. Other California organizations in opposition to Proposition 23 included the American Lung Association in California, California Professional Firefighters, AARP, California Nurses Association, the California Democratic Party, National Venture Capital Association, the California Solar Energy Industries Association and California Wind Energy Association.

“This proposition saw opposition from everyone from military leaders to religious leaders,” Crowfoot said.

While Proposition 23 was aimed at California’s unemployment rate, opponents of the proposition said it would have jeopardized the jobs of over 500,000 Californians employed in renewable energy, a rapidly growing job market. Since the implementation of AB 32, California has garnered over $9 billion of private investment capital, a market that a ‘yes’ on Proposition 23 would have been endangered, said rivals of the proposition.

“The defeat of Proposition 23 tells Congress that the largest state in the Union that represents the eighth largest economy in the world is a cornerstone of economic recovery, and that Californians view clean energy as part of the solution,” Crowfoot said.

Tom Rooney, president and CEO of SPG Solar, said California has become a “consistent, predictable market for solar,” and the passing of Proposition 23 could have derailed that stability. While Rooney was on a trip to China two months ago, he met a solar developer who was planning on building a $100 million solar facility in California after deciding that California was the most durable solar market in the U.S. and globally. Rooney said the passing of Proposition 23 would have caused global solar companies developing in the U.S. to second guess themselves about the market stability.

He said that solar is a huge bolster to economies worldwide, particularly Germany. However, countries like Spain that have dabbled in solar, only to later change renewable energy policies, “have waffled.”

The defeat of Proposition 23 shows that the average Californian is aware of the benefits spurred by renewable energy, Rooney said.

“Voters are figuring out that investing in renewable energy equals job creation, fiscal responsibility, energy independence and environmental benefits.”

While Proposition 23 may have given some California renewable developers a scare, Rooney said that in the end, it benefitted renewable energy. “Proposition 23 got people talking about renewable energy, and if the grassroots’ population is talking about an issue, enormous power comes out of that.”

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Just Who Is Saying "No" To Proposition 23?

Oct. 13, 2010 -

Supporters of renewable energy are emerging to champion the "no" campaign to California's Proposition 23 amidst worries of the future for the renewables industry in California. On Sept. 27, I wrote about the California renewables' tug-of-war. Will California continue to be the forerunner in the U.S. when it comes to the development of renewable energy, or will Proposition 23 pass, slowing down that ship?

On Nov. 2, Californians will vote on Proposition 23, which has been created to suspend A.B. 32, a law that requires cutting carbon and other greenhouse emissions to 1990 levels by 2020 by mandating power companies to cap their emissions and by slashing carbon in gasoline. Proposition 23 would keep the law from going into effect in 2012 until California's unemployment falls to 5.5 percent or lower for at least four consecutive quarters. Since that has happened just three times over the last 40 years, the passing of the proposition could effectually kill A.B. 32.

About 74 percent of the "Yes" campaign contributions for Proposition 23 have come from oil companies Tesoro and Valero, and Flint Hills Resources, the petrochemical company owned by Kansas billionaires Charles and David Koch, according to campaign records.

But just 20 days before the election, foes of the proposition have spent twice as much as the backers on campaigning efforts. However, Steven Maviglio, a spokesman for the main "No" campaign, told The New York Times that he expects the "Yes" campaign to "drop of nuclear bomb" of campaigning in the coming weeks.

Many of the main contributors to the "No" campaign are involved in renewable developments of some sort. Wendy Schmidt, a philanthropist and wife of Eric Schmidt, Google’s chief executive, has donated $500,000. Google made renewable energy headlines with the Oct. 11 announcement that it will spend $5 billion on an underwater transmission network that will harvest electricity from wind farms off the Mid-Atlantic coast and power 1.9 million homes across Virginia, New York and New Jersey.

Members of San Francisco’s Fisher family, founders of the Gap clothing chain, have donated more than $ 1 million. Gap Inc. has its own social responsibility campaign, which includes an environmental segment that teaches people how to lessen their environmental footprint. The company also makes its annual energy consumption numbers public information through its web site.

Foes of Proposition 23 are abounding at the same time that nationwide expectancy of renewables growth, particularly solar, is all abuzz.

A solar jobs census conducted by The Solar Foundation with the help of Cornell University tallied 93,000 solar power industry jobs in the United States as of August, and projects industry job growth of 26 percent in 2011. According to the survey's results, roughly half of solar employers plan to add employees next year, compared with just 2 percent for private industry economy-wide.

Will California supporters of renewables and the public's belief and expectations in clean energy put an end to Proposition 23? Nov. 2 will tell.

Monday, September 27, 2010

California Enters the Renewables Tug-Of-War

Sept. 27, 2010 -

On Sept. 23, the California Air Resources Board approved regulations requiring utilities to obtain a third of their power from alternative energy sources such as wind, solar and geothermal in 10 years. California now gets nearly 14 percent of its electricity from renewable sources, and the state is pushing utilities to reach a 20-percent-renewable energy standard by next year.

At a time when some legislators are pulling for the developments of renewable energy, a ballot initiative known as Proposition 23 is tugging in the opposite direction. In a state with a 12.4-percent unemployment rate, the debate over whether a renewable energy standard will create or kill jobs has been heated. The tug-of-war for renewables’ future in California – and possibly nationwide – is on full force.

A.B. 32, the 2006-implimented law in question, requires cutting carbon and other greenhouse emissions to 1990 levels by 2020 by mandating power companies to cap their emissions and by slashing carbon in gasoline. Some oil industry leaders said it would necessitate investing millions of dollars to comply, forcing companies to cut jobs and raise the price of gas at the pumps.

On Nov. 2, Californians will vote on Proposition 23, which has been created to suspend the law from going into effect in 2012 until state unemployment falls to 5.5 percent or lower for at least four consecutive quarters. Since that has happened just three times over the last 40 years, the passing of the proposition could effectually kill A.B. 32.

Largely behind the financial support of Proposition 23 are Charles and David Koch, the Kansas billionaires who own the oil company Flint Hills Resources. With their contribution, backers of the proposition have raised $8.2 million, with $7.9 million coming from energy companies outside of California.

The California power industry is stuck in the middle of the debate, with developers unsure whether to move forward full-force in establishing higher percentage renewable portfolios, or to pull back in uncertainty of A.B. 32’s future.

Some large developers continue to push forward. On Wednesday, the California Energy Commission approved plans from BrightSource Energy Inc. to build a 370 MW solar plant in the Mojave Desert.

Still other solar companies are in limbo until the threat of Proposition 23 has been lifted.

Mike Hall, CEO of San Diego-based Borrego Solar, said that power companies approach Borrego for solar consulting or installations because they have an initiative to reduce carbon emissions and develop renewable energy portfolios, and that Proposition 23 brings a degree of uncertainty to these efforts and the power sector at large.

“Everyone is expecting the market to be driven by the renewable portfolio standard and the value of carbon reduction. If we start to bring those things into question, it becomes very unclear where the industry in California goes next.”

Outside of California, Hall said the passing of Proposition 23 could cause reticence toward carbon legislation and renewable portfolio standards.

“I think it would motivate those businesses who have an interest in drilling down those regulations to try harder in other states,” said Hall. “Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, New Jersey and many other states are emerging as solar players as well, and that is largely due to progressive policy.”

Hall said that short-term, Proposition 23 would stall renewable energy growth in California, but long-term it could also have damaging effects on nationwide solar and renewable energy policies.

Skyline Solar is a 2007 start-up solar technology company based out of Mountain View, Calif. Tim Keating, vice president of marketing and field operations, said that while he does not see the passing Proposition 23 to be likely, it could cause California solar companies to focus on overseas exports to countries more welcoming of renewables if it did pass.

“We need a healthy home market,” Keating said. “Until Congress gets a renewable energy bill, we need the states to innovate.”

Keating said the potential passing of Proposition 23 would have more long-term effects, pulling California out of the leadership position in renewables it has established and weakening nationwide renewables legislation.

“Long term, it would back flight the momentum we’re gaining towards a real renewable energy policy.”

For now, California power companies watch carefully to determine their next step, enduring the game of tug-of-war until the outcome of the Nov. 2 Proposition 23 vote gives more clarity.