The Up In The Air blog discusses what's floating around concerning EPA emissions rules, and what the power industry is doing to prepare for regulations. You'll also find discussions about Smart Grid and other developments pertinent to the power industry.
Showing posts with label coal-fired power plants. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coal-fired power plants. Show all posts
Friday, April 15, 2011
EPA's hint to coal generators (shhh...it's natural gas!)
As a newlywed 10 months into marriage, I’m still learning that dropping hints is not always the strongest form of communication. I might mention to my husband all week long things like, “Doesn’t queso from such-and-such restaurant sound good?” Then the weekend rolls around, and he still innocently asks, “What kind of restaurant should we try?” Sometimes hints aren’t picked up on. Or even if they are, they aren’t always acted upon. But still, it's often more comfortable, less abrasive to use hints in place of direct communication. It seems to me that the Environmental Protection Agency is a hint-dropper. The Administration doesn’t come out and force conversions from coal to natural gas or renewables. But through nagging mechanisms even more powerful than those possessed by the cast of Desperate Housewives, the EPA can make life tough on coal-fired generators. On April 14, I attended an EPA hearing in Tulsa, Okla. concerning an ongoing debate over three coal-fired plants that are not under compliance of EPA’s Clean Air Visibility Rule. The plants are Oklahoma Gas and Electric (OG&E) Company’s Muskogee and Sooner Stations, and AEP-Public Service Company of Oklahoma’s Red Rock Station. According to the rule, the stations must achieve EPA’s emission limit for SO2 – 0.15 lb/mmBtu, or 95 percent removal. OG&E said it would cost about $10,000 per ton to reduce SO2 emissions to those levels through the use of scrubber technology at its two plants. The Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality (ODEQ) has submitted a State Implementation Plan (SIP), recommending Best Available Retrofit Technology (BART) switches for the plants. However, the EPA identified the SIP as one that “does not meet one or more of the required elements.” Why doesn’t it meet the requirements? Steve Thompson, executive director of ODEQ, said the BART alternative in the SIP “reduces SO2 emissions more than the primary requirements in EPA’s Federal Implementation Plan.” So what about that is unacceptable to the EPA? Coal is still being burned. Visibility could still be affected to some degree in federal wildlife areas – the heart of the issue. EPA states that “switches to natural gas are an acceptable method,” as a spokesperson from Oklahoma natural gas producer Chesapeake Energy pointed out at the hearing. Oklahoma has an abundant supply of natural gas. Larry Nichols, CEO of Devon Energy, told me during a March interview that the company’s work in the Cana shale in western Oklahoma which has already netted 11 trillion cubic feet – larger than Devon’s four discoveries in the Gulf of Mexico. So a shortage of a natural gas supply would be close to impossible if these power companies were to do a partial or total switch. It’s not just these Oklahoma coal plants that will soon be replaced by natural gas or another form of “cleaner” energy. On April 14, Tennessee Valley Authority announced the retirement of 18 coal-fired units. In many cases, it’s easier to retire a plant than to retrofit it, especially older plants. Barney Racine, software development manger for the environmental solutions group of Honeywell Process Solutions, said the EPA’s focus is not so much on SO2 control, but rather a complete retreat from coal. “They’re not necessarily driving legislation from the emissions monitoring standpoint, but from the incentive side – the cost to burn coal vs. natural gas.” Some coal will undoubtedly remain in the generation mix in the coming decades, but EPA will continue to drop hints that other forms of generation are preferable. While natural gas prices are low, many coal-fired generators will, reluctantly or not, make the switch. EPA’s hint will be taken with a grain of salt, or perhaps in some cases, enforced. And hopefully through tactful hints rather than a means of force even more powerful than the EPA's, I’ll get my chips and queso this weekend.
Labels:
AEP,
Chesapeake,
coal-fired power plants,
Devon Energy,
EPA Clean Air Visibility,
natural gas power plants,
Oklahoma Department of Environmental Quality,
Oklahoma Gas and Electric,
PSO
Friday, September 10, 2010
Clean Air Transport Rule: What’s a State To Do?
Sept. 10, 2010-
During a webcast on Sept. 10, EPA directors spoke on the topic of “Urgent CAIR: EPA's New Clean Air Transport Rule.” Sam Napolitano, director of EPA’s clean air markets division, said the transport rule, which is slated to take effect in 2012, will replace the Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). The transport rule, signed on July 6, 2010, includes CAIR requirements, but also achieves emissions reductions concerning the transport of air pollution across state boundaries that are beyond those included in CAIR.
The EPA is proposing one approach and taking comments on two alternatives. All three approaches would cover and set a pollution limit for 31 states and the District of Columbia that have unacceptable SO2 and/or NOx levels according to the EPA. (Click here to see a map of the states affected). The first approach – which is EPA’s preferred approach – allows intrastate trading and limited interstate trading among power plants but requires each state to meet its own emissions control obligations. The second approach allows for trading among power plants within a state. And in the third approach, EPA specifies the allowable emission limit for each power plant and allows some averaging of emission rates.
EPA estimates compliance costs for the industry will be 2.8 billion in 2014. Most of these costs are projected to be spent on scrubbers (Flue Gas Desulfurization (FGD)) and Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) units, and the operation and implementation of all such controls.
To meet the proposed rule, EPA anticipates power plants will operate previously installed control equipment more frequently, use lower sulfur coal, or install pollution control equipment such as low NOX burners, SCR or FGD.
Some individuals in the power industry have raised concerns that the proposed switch to low sulfur coal could be EPA’s disguised advance toward increased natural gas dependence.
During the webinar, Napolitano addressed EPA’s intentions regarding the switch. “Mainly it is coal-fuel switching, not gas. It is only a 1 percent change in coal production.” Napoloitano said EPA’s goal is to have all power plants operating as cleanly as possible in the long run, adding that EPA estimates that in terms of size, 1.2 GW of power plants will be shut down as a result of the transport rule.
To assure rapid compliance with the new emissions control standards, EPA is proposing federal implementation plans (FIPs), for each of the states covered by this rule. A state may choose to develop its own plan to reach the required reductions, replacing its federal plan, and may select which types of sources to control. The Clean Air Act requires states to submit plans to cut down on interstate pollution transport before they submit plans to meet ambient air quality standards. By determining the amount of emissions that upwind states must eliminate in advance of the time that state pollution transport plans are due, EPA plans to enact timely reductions in pollution transport. When downwind states design their plans to meet the air quality standards, they will know how much upwind state control is required. This plan is intended to enable the Clean Air Act to work as planned, helping downwind states to attain standards sooner.
The state budgets for SO2, annual NOX, and ozone season NOX are directly linked to the measurement of each state’s significant contribution and interference with maintenance. EPA’s remedy includes provisions to ensure that all necessary reductions occur in each individual state. EPA poses to allow within-state trading and limited interstate trading to assure that, in each state, the emissions that contribute the most to downwind air quality problems will be eliminated.
CAIR will remain in place until this rule is finalized. The final air transport rule is expected in late spring 2011. More information on the proposed rules and details on how to comment on the proposal are available at http://www.epa.gov/airtransport.
During a webcast on Sept. 10, EPA directors spoke on the topic of “Urgent CAIR: EPA's New Clean Air Transport Rule.” Sam Napolitano, director of EPA’s clean air markets division, said the transport rule, which is slated to take effect in 2012, will replace the Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). The transport rule, signed on July 6, 2010, includes CAIR requirements, but also achieves emissions reductions concerning the transport of air pollution across state boundaries that are beyond those included in CAIR.
The EPA is proposing one approach and taking comments on two alternatives. All three approaches would cover and set a pollution limit for 31 states and the District of Columbia that have unacceptable SO2 and/or NOx levels according to the EPA. (Click here to see a map of the states affected). The first approach – which is EPA’s preferred approach – allows intrastate trading and limited interstate trading among power plants but requires each state to meet its own emissions control obligations. The second approach allows for trading among power plants within a state. And in the third approach, EPA specifies the allowable emission limit for each power plant and allows some averaging of emission rates.
EPA estimates compliance costs for the industry will be 2.8 billion in 2014. Most of these costs are projected to be spent on scrubbers (Flue Gas Desulfurization (FGD)) and Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) units, and the operation and implementation of all such controls.
To meet the proposed rule, EPA anticipates power plants will operate previously installed control equipment more frequently, use lower sulfur coal, or install pollution control equipment such as low NOX burners, SCR or FGD.
Some individuals in the power industry have raised concerns that the proposed switch to low sulfur coal could be EPA’s disguised advance toward increased natural gas dependence.
During the webinar, Napolitano addressed EPA’s intentions regarding the switch. “Mainly it is coal-fuel switching, not gas. It is only a 1 percent change in coal production.” Napoloitano said EPA’s goal is to have all power plants operating as cleanly as possible in the long run, adding that EPA estimates that in terms of size, 1.2 GW of power plants will be shut down as a result of the transport rule.
To assure rapid compliance with the new emissions control standards, EPA is proposing federal implementation plans (FIPs), for each of the states covered by this rule. A state may choose to develop its own plan to reach the required reductions, replacing its federal plan, and may select which types of sources to control. The Clean Air Act requires states to submit plans to cut down on interstate pollution transport before they submit plans to meet ambient air quality standards. By determining the amount of emissions that upwind states must eliminate in advance of the time that state pollution transport plans are due, EPA plans to enact timely reductions in pollution transport. When downwind states design their plans to meet the air quality standards, they will know how much upwind state control is required. This plan is intended to enable the Clean Air Act to work as planned, helping downwind states to attain standards sooner.
The state budgets for SO2, annual NOX, and ozone season NOX are directly linked to the measurement of each state’s significant contribution and interference with maintenance. EPA’s remedy includes provisions to ensure that all necessary reductions occur in each individual state. EPA poses to allow within-state trading and limited interstate trading to assure that, in each state, the emissions that contribute the most to downwind air quality problems will be eliminated.
CAIR will remain in place until this rule is finalized. The final air transport rule is expected in late spring 2011. More information on the proposed rules and details on how to comment on the proposal are available at http://www.epa.gov/airtransport.
Monday, July 12, 2010
Shale plays: Vaulted treasure for power industry?
July 12, 2010 -
Before joining Power Engineering, I wrote about oil and gas. For the last few years, the hot topic in O&G has been shale plays. Plays like the Barnett, Marcellus, and Haynesville are hotter than Lebron's switch to the Heat. Acquisition prices for such plays are soaring into the billions.
But when it comes to the power industry, I'm learning that shale plays are virtually useless -- at least for now. Like a treasure stored in an impenetrable vault, shale plays have need for much development both on the midstream O&G side, as well as the power operations side. To start with, pipelines to transfer the natural gas from the plays to plants are virtually non-existent. In addition, even if a smooth transport system were developed, coal-fired power plants can't be easily retrofitted to burn gas.
Last week, the American Public Power Association (APPA) released a new natural gas report: Implications of Greater Reliance on Natural Gas for Electricity Generation. Among the findings, Aspen Environmental Group, who conducted the research, uncovered "no instances of coal plant retrofits to natural gas." Not only is switching all coal-fired generation to natural gas impossible due to insufficient natural gas supply, but the entire plant infrastructure would have to be wiped clean.
"It would be more feasible and cost-effective to construct new natural gas units or to dispatch excess capacity at existing natural gas units than to convert a coal plant because of technical and economic factors." -GAO, “Implications of Switching from Coal to Natural Gas,” GAO-08-601R, May 1, 2008. Found at:
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d08601r.pdf
Not only does retrofitting a coal-fired plant to natural gas seem impossible, but such a retrofit would also leave certain areas with insufficient system resources. It would take four to six months to complete all of the retrofits, and that would lead to a number of brownouts or blackouts.
And let's not forget about air permits. While some would say the EPA shows favoritism towards natural gas-fired facilities, at least three air permit issues would still exist:
1) Patriculate matter (PM). If the natural gas-fired unit is larger than the coal-fired unit that it replaced or is in operation even more (which it most likely would be), the particulate emissions may be even higher for the gas unit.
2) The National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for nitrogen dioxide (NO2). This rule implimented a new 1-hour standard for ambient NO2 at 100 parts per billion. The concern is that background ambient NO2 levels would be determined by monitors placed near highways. "This will force urban areas into nonattainment and trigger more stringent permitting requirements for NGCCs," according to the APPA report.
3)CO₂. It's the great air regulation mystery floating around these days (no pun intended). How will CO₂ be regulated? As long as the Clean Air Act regulates CO₂ and Greenhouse Gases (GHGs), Best Available Control Technology (BACT) requirements at power plants will require some type of controls on CO₂ emissions.
Oh, and one more regulation to keep in mind for the future: the regulation of hydrochloric acid (HCI). EPA plans to regulate HCI from smaller combustion units under the Industrial and Commerical Boiler Maximum Available Control Technology (MACT) requirement. EPA has not yet proposed any HCI limit for natural gas-fired utilities, but future compliance obligations should be assumed.
While shale plays may seem like a hidden treasure for the oil and gas industry, it's going to be a long road before these natural gas resources would start to be of value to the power industry. Retrofits for switching from coal to natural gas seem to be out of the question; therefore, it would be years before most plants could/would switch to natural gas-fired. And even still, EPA would have emissions regulations on natural gas-fired plants.
Are shale plays a vaulted treasure that the power industry should leave vaulted, or are they worth all the trouble?
Before joining Power Engineering, I wrote about oil and gas. For the last few years, the hot topic in O&G has been shale plays. Plays like the Barnett, Marcellus, and Haynesville are hotter than Lebron's switch to the Heat. Acquisition prices for such plays are soaring into the billions.
But when it comes to the power industry, I'm learning that shale plays are virtually useless -- at least for now. Like a treasure stored in an impenetrable vault, shale plays have need for much development both on the midstream O&G side, as well as the power operations side. To start with, pipelines to transfer the natural gas from the plays to plants are virtually non-existent. In addition, even if a smooth transport system were developed, coal-fired power plants can't be easily retrofitted to burn gas.
Last week, the American Public Power Association (APPA) released a new natural gas report: Implications of Greater Reliance on Natural Gas for Electricity Generation. Among the findings, Aspen Environmental Group, who conducted the research, uncovered "no instances of coal plant retrofits to natural gas." Not only is switching all coal-fired generation to natural gas impossible due to insufficient natural gas supply, but the entire plant infrastructure would have to be wiped clean.
"It would be more feasible and cost-effective to construct new natural gas units or to dispatch excess capacity at existing natural gas units than to convert a coal plant because of technical and economic factors." -GAO, “Implications of Switching from Coal to Natural Gas,” GAO-08-601R, May 1, 2008. Found at:
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d08601r.pdf
Not only does retrofitting a coal-fired plant to natural gas seem impossible, but such a retrofit would also leave certain areas with insufficient system resources. It would take four to six months to complete all of the retrofits, and that would lead to a number of brownouts or blackouts.
And let's not forget about air permits. While some would say the EPA shows favoritism towards natural gas-fired facilities, at least three air permit issues would still exist:
1) Patriculate matter (PM). If the natural gas-fired unit is larger than the coal-fired unit that it replaced or is in operation even more (which it most likely would be), the particulate emissions may be even higher for the gas unit.
2) The National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for nitrogen dioxide (NO2). This rule implimented a new 1-hour standard for ambient NO2 at 100 parts per billion. The concern is that background ambient NO2 levels would be determined by monitors placed near highways. "This will force urban areas into nonattainment and trigger more stringent permitting requirements for NGCCs," according to the APPA report.
3)CO₂. It's the great air regulation mystery floating around these days (no pun intended). How will CO₂ be regulated? As long as the Clean Air Act regulates CO₂ and Greenhouse Gases (GHGs), Best Available Control Technology (BACT) requirements at power plants will require some type of controls on CO₂ emissions.
Oh, and one more regulation to keep in mind for the future: the regulation of hydrochloric acid (HCI). EPA plans to regulate HCI from smaller combustion units under the Industrial and Commerical Boiler Maximum Available Control Technology (MACT) requirement. EPA has not yet proposed any HCI limit for natural gas-fired utilities, but future compliance obligations should be assumed.
While shale plays may seem like a hidden treasure for the oil and gas industry, it's going to be a long road before these natural gas resources would start to be of value to the power industry. Retrofits for switching from coal to natural gas seem to be out of the question; therefore, it would be years before most plants could/would switch to natural gas-fired. And even still, EPA would have emissions regulations on natural gas-fired plants.
Are shale plays a vaulted treasure that the power industry should leave vaulted, or are they worth all the trouble?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)