Showing posts with label EPA regulations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EPA regulations. Show all posts

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Greenhouse gas regulations: Fact or fiction?

To what can greenhouse gas standards for fossil-fuel fired plants be compared? Remember the children’s story Jumanji? Perhaps you saw the 1995 Robin Williams’ movie based on the story. Two kids play an old magic board-game that releases a man trapped for decades, as well as a number of dangers that can only be ended by finishing the game. But as long as the kids follow the instructions and complete the game, they are promised survival.

Such is the state of the fossil-fuel fired sector when it comes to complying with greenhouse gas regulations. But compliance is no game, and the road to it is far from fiction.

“Read the instructions and follow the rules, and things can get pretty hair-rising. But if you follow the rules, you can survive it,” said a power industry representative on Feb. 4, comparing emissions regulatory compliance with Jumanji. This was one of the many comments made during the EPA-hosted listening session on greenhouse gas standards for fossil-fuel fired power plants and petroleum refineries. This first of five listening sessions was intended for electric power industry representatives.

Much of the commentary centered on a push for a sector-wide generation performance standard. Some industry representatives said EPA should offer a fleet-wide approach to allow averaging and the use of offsets. Some suggested that an emissions rate-based approach would be the most innovative and least burdensome way to implement a performance standard.

Gina McCarthy, assistant administrator for the EPA office of air and radiation, said that EPA’s goal is not to decide on a number for greenhouse gases that ought to be reached. “It’s not a cap and trade program. We do not have a greenhouse gas number that we’re looking to achieve.”

While the greenhouse gas facet of the Clean Air Act is in question, other regulations have already taken a toll on the industry. A representative from FirstEnergy Corp. mentioned retrofits recently made at the W.H. Sammis Plant in Stratton, Ohio. Efficiency on the units was lost after scrubbers were installed, the representative said. “How do we maintain our efficiency as we go forward?” Price signals help FirstEnergy and other merchants determine how to invest in their fleet, the representative said, urging EPA to set a price signal.

New Source Performance Standards (NSPS) are also a topic of debate. A representative from the American Public Power Association urged the EPA to take its time “to get NSPS right,” adding that EPA is not under a court under to have standards finalized by July.

“I will not tell you what the breadth of the New Source Performance Standard is going to look like,” McCarthy said. “EPA is interested in walking before running.”

“Walking before running” – could this be an implication that EPA will take its time in finalizing NSPS? The listening sessions and public commentary may lead EPA to prolong decisions that have many in the power industry have been rushed. Time will tell. Until then, coal-fired power producers will continue to jump through hoops, fight monsters, and weather the storms that come with living the stranger than fiction story that is emissions control compliance.

If you are unable to participate in one of the listening sessions, EPA is accepting written comments on the planned rulemakings until March 18, 2011.

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

What is “clean energy,” President Obama?

President Barack Obama has launched what is to be a new era of clean energy development in the U.S., announcing that this could be a “Sputnik moment.” During the Jan. 25 State of the Union address, he urged Americans to rally around a new goal: Obtaining 80 percent of America's electricity from clean energy sources by 2035.

While to some, Obama’s announcement means the accelerated growth of renewable energy, “clean energy” can be broadly defined. To conservationists, "clean energy" would likely mean 100 percent renewable energy. To others, "clean energy" could mean 100 percent clean coal. My understanding is that President Obama is referring to a combination of all the resources -- renewable energy, nuclear, natural gas, and yes, even clean coal.

“It is a very ambitious goal, and it is also a very vague and broad goal,” said Jeff Davis, co-head of the renewable energy practice at the Mayer Brown law firm.

Currently, the U.S. coal fleet generates roughly half of all electrical output. “There are reports that we’ll still be using the same percentage from coal in 2035. It will just be clean coal,” Davis said. According to the North American Electric Reliability Corporation, coal-fired generation will drop to less than one-third of total generation by 2030 – less than half, but still a sizeable amount.

While the definition of clean coal is unclear, renewable energy is expected to continue to grow in the coming decades. Davis said that the ripening of this “low-hanging fruit” – wind and solar is “key to the continued support of clean energy.”

In order to reach the goal of 80 percent clean energy by 2035, Denise Bode, CEO of the American Wind Energy Association, said renewable energy incentives and policies must reach a place of predictability allowing that “energy sources that will never run out ... instead of keeping renewable energy on a constant one-year footing.”

In December, the U.S. House approved the passage of a tax bill that includes a one-year extension of Section 1603 (Treasury Grant Program). Incentives for renewables typically have been extended one year at a time, leaving renewable energy industries little room to plan long-term projects and investments.

“It’s time to reorient the tax code to predictable policies,” Bode said. “Predictability of the permanent incentives for conventional energy sources is as important as the amounts.”

Davis said that incentives for renewable energy are a must, but the source for funding incentives is questionable. “A large part of the State of the Union address focused on deficits and reducing them, but at the same time the President is talking about providing incentives for clean energy. How do we pay for these incentives?”

The President seemed to signal that energy incentives could come from the reduction of oil subsidies. The oil subsidies vs. renewable energy incentives debate will be an interesting one to watch as it unfolds in the new Congress, given the historic way in which the different sides of the aisle have voted.

According to Obama, clean energy is an “investment that will strengthen our security, protect our planet and create countless new jobs for our people.” If clean energy is defined as renewable energy, then this goal could prove to be lofty. But if clean energy is a mix of clean coal, nuclear, renewable energy and natural gas, then this goal is undoudtedly attainable. The current and proposed U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) emissions control regulations alone are enough to guarantee that all existing coal in 2035 will be "clean."

“It’s advantageous to define the goal broadly in order to achieve it,” Davis said.

While the bar has been set, it will be up to Congress to pass legislation that allows the goal of 80 percent clean energy by 2035 to come to pass.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

Greenhouse gas regulations and political hijinks

How will greenhouse gas (GHG) regulations affect new and stationary sources? Will GHGs play a role in the 2012 presidential elections? During a recent Bracewell & Giuliani LLP press conference, partners such as former EPA air administrator Jeff Holmstead, congressional/refining expert Scott Segal and former EPA enforcement official Rich Alonso took part in a discussion centering on these topics.

On Dec. 23, 2010, the EPA issued its plan for establishing greenhouse gas pollution standards under the Clean Air Act (CAA) in 2011. This included reference to New Source Performance Standards, which set the level of pollution new facilities may emit and address air pollution from existing facilities.

Holmstead said EPA is incorrect to say that new and modified sources are not yet regulated; “There’s just no standard for what they have to meet. Right now, developers are faced with undergoing a process that gives them a standard, but don’t yet know what the standard is going to be or how they’re going to get there.” This uncertainty, Holmstead said, has caused the construction moratorium.

“EPA is acknowledging that it’s going to be a couple years before people see these new permits.”

However, NSPS are more favorable than the typical EPA permitting processes, Holmstead said, and this could impact the effectiveness of the end product. “This is the big issue that EPA faces: if they do what’s sensible and reasonable for coal-fired power, they might get a 2 to 5 percent reduction in greenhouse gases.

EPA may not be willing to undergo this less strenuous process in order to reduce emissions by a few percentage points, Holmstead said.

Texas, where a federal court has denied the state’s attempts to delay U.S. environmental regulators from imposing regulations on greenhouse gases, will face construction being put on hold for at least a couple years, Holmstead said.

“I’m confident in saying that nobody in Texas will have legitimate authority to build a new project in at least two years, and that would be lightning speed.”

Segal spoke on how EPA regulations could affect political positions, and vice versa. Delays of one to two years in regards to emissions rule-making “could set up an unfortunate collision course with the presidential election.” A three-year delay on EPA’s behalf could allow the Agency to “operate from the position of political hijinks.”

While discussions have been made on how Congress will handle the greenhouse gas regulations, Segal said that Senate’s reaction to the standards will be something to watch. “Harry Reid has been a strong defender of premium renewable energy.” Among the 10 Senate Republicans, 100 percent voted for the last floor vote on a resolution of disapproval for global greenhouse gases. In addition, of the 21 Democrats up for re-election, 10 are from states in which a vote seen as favorable to greenhouse gas regulatory authority “would be a political liability.”

“That doesn’t mean they’re going to vote in favor of an amendment, it just means in 2012, they would have some ‘splainin’ to do if they voted against it,” Segal said.

The Bracewell & Giuliani team also discussed the Jan. 12 EPA announcement to defer biomass from greenhouse gas permitting requirements for three years. Alonso said that because biofuels are not yet under the structure of the CAA, this provides an incentive to build biomass. However, Alonso said that EPA has created a problem for itself.

“They have announced this as a three-year delay, but it’s not clear if this is legal.” Alonso said this policy will likely be challenged “because biomass does emit carbon.”

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Power industry of 2011, meet environmental regulations

Welcome to 2011! Amidst news of falling natural gas prices and wind power projects meeting dead ends, most power generators will have a unified focus this year: preparing for EPA regulations in the hopper.

Waiting on regulation announcements and researching what needs to happen at power plants in order to meet standards – these seem to be in the crystal ball for the power markets this year. 2011 has commenced with a focus on greenhouse gas emissions regulations, as the EPA seeks to create a federal standard for greenhouse gases, and lawmakers have protested through at least four different bills to date. These bills seek to thwart greenhouse gas regulations from taking effect for two years.

Meanwhile, Texas and the EPA are involved in the fiercest part of the greenhouse gas regulations spat, as Texas is the only state that has refused to issue a greenhouse gas permit process. EPA filed a brief with the DC Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington on Jan. 6 saying that EPA is the “ultimate supervisor’’ if a state fails to develop or enforce an acceptable plan. Twelve other states continue to work with EPA to develop process guidelines.

On Jan. 7, Texas filed a brief with the Court saying that EPA did not follow procedures to seize control of the state’s permit process and did not provide sufficient notice or open the decision to comment. Texas and the EPA expect a ruling from the Court this week in their case.

Aside from greenhouse gas regulations, a number of other regulations are slated to be proposed or enforced in 2011 (see page 5 of this ICF International study). The North American Electric Reliability Council (NERC) predicts that these four rules could have the greatest impact on electric reliability:

-Clean Water Act Section 316(b), Cooling Water Intake Structures
-Coal Combustion Residuals Disposal regulations
-Clean Air Transport Rule
-Title III of the Clean Air Act; National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) for the electric power industry or Maximum Achievable Control Technology (MACT) Standard

In its 2010 Long-Term Reliability Assessment, NERC stated that the proposed rulemaking adds a degree of uncertainty to future planning of generation capacity needs. When considering the repercussions of these regulations on existing and planned generation capacity over the next 10 years, NERC found that, “Depending on the outcome of any or all of these regulations, the results may accelerate the retirement of some fossil fuel–fired power plants.”

John Moura, technical analyst for NERC, said the timing of several regulations being enacted in a short period of time will have its effect on electric reliability.

“The major driver of concern is going to be the time the industry has to react to these issues,” Moura said.

Recent studies by ICF International, NERC and Credit Suisse estimate anywhere from 10 to 75 GW of coal capacity are at risk for retirement by 2020. Retiring such a large percentage of the fleet could put electric reliability at risk, as could retrofits, Moura said.

“A utility has to take a unit offline to put a scrubber in. That kind of coordination in a condensed period of time can really create some issues both in the adequacy and in the operating reliability.”

2011 – a year for both regulation enforcement and the introduction of new proposals. Generators will seek to comply with new regulations and prepare for future regulations, while attempting to grow the North American electric system into an even more reliable, flawless network.

Friday, November 19, 2010

A mission to fight emissions non-compliance

Dr. Sue Tierney, former Massachusetts state regulator and Department of Energy official, is set on waking up some in the power industry from a sluggish state. Tierney’s mission is to show the industry that compliance with U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) regulations should not be delayed.

Tierney is also lead author of a reliability report, Ensuring a Clean, Modern Electric Generating Fleet while Maintaining Electric System Reliability, a gathering of information on the industry’s readiness for compliance.

According to two July 2010 studies by the Energy Information Administration, the combination of low energy prices and EPA air regulations could result in the retirements of between 25 to 40 GW of the nation’s 1,030 GW of electric generating capacity. Although some plants may be retired, Tierney’s report found that approximately half of the nation’s coal-fired generating capacity (150 GW) has already installed SO2 scrubbers, another 55 GW plan to install scrubbers and a significant number of coal units have already announced plans to retire. That necessitates one-fourth of the nation’s coal-fired generation to add pollution controls, switch to a cleaner fuel or retire.

Despite all of the changes needed to be made on units in the next few years as a result of the air, coal ash rules and water rules, Tierney is confident that the electric industry is prepared to meet the challenge. Her reliability report found that each North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) reliability region has excess capacity, totaling over 100 GW of excess capacity nationwide. In fact, between 2001 and 2003, the electric industry built over 160 GW of new generation – about four times what analysts project will retire over the next five years. Therefore, even if projected retirement scenarios prove accurate, the likelihood of capacity shortages is slim, Tierney said.

Tierney’s platform is that the electric industry is well-positioned to respond to emissions regulations, with commercially available NOx, SO2, mercury and acid gas control technologies. Many coal plants have already been fitted with scrubbers: Between 2008 to 2010, approximately 60 GW of coal capacity was installed with scrubbers, with the industry completing more than 50 scrubber retrofits each year, the report found. Tierney said those in the industry who are delaying do so out of an impression that tarrying will be to their financial benefit.

“The friends of delay could create the very problem they’re saying they don’t want to have happen by getting everyone on the delay bandwagon. Then people won’t start to make decisions and figuring out how they’re going to comply soon enough,” Tierney said.

Among the many rules that EPA is addressing, the transport rule for SOx and NOx and the hazardous air rules for mercury are under court order under existing law for power plants to implement necessary changes, Tierney said. “I think debating whether that is worthy of considered delay is a tactic which would have unfortunate consequences.”

However, the EPA has much more discretion over the water rules, which will determine what kind of cooling system changes if any need to be made at existing plants. Tierney said those rules may be worthy of considering delay.

Tierney said emissions regulations are just one set of the many rules that the industry has responded to over the last 30 years. “Simultaneously we’ve been able to afford keeping the lights on and providing relatively affordable electricity supply.”

While Tierney is confident that the emissions adjustments are doable, some in the industry argue that time and money spent on control technology implementation are time and money taken away from research and development. Tierney, however, said she has witnessed many experiences in which government requirements have stimulated problem solving and innovation in response to compliance requirements. In addition, “From an industry point of view, the folks who work on R&D are not the folks who work on the engineering of solutions.”

Tierney’s standpoint is that the electric sector is well-positioned to respond to EPA’s mission to “help millions of Americans breathe easier and live healthier” without threatening electric reliability. “With economic costs, there will also be economic benefits related to health as well as investment/construction stimulus.”

She said that industry studies that raise the spotlight on reliability issues do not typically incorporate assumptions about how the market will respond and therefore are not necessarily sound pictures of what will occur. Existing substantial excess capacity, the electric industry’s proven track record to timely construct new generation and to efficiently coordinate the scheduling of planned outages, together with transmission enhancements, smart grid investments, fuel conversions, relatively low gas prices and demand-side actions should mitigate reliability and cost concerns, Tierney said.

“As a final backstop, existing statutory, market and regulatory safeguards will facilitate the retirement of inefficient units, and an orderly transition to cleaner, more efficient generation.”

Click here to read the entire report (PDF) co-authored by Dr. Tierney.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Clean Air Transport Rule: What’s a State To Do?

Sept. 10, 2010-

During a webcast on Sept. 10, EPA directors spoke on the topic of “Urgent CAIR: EPA's New Clean Air Transport Rule.” Sam Napolitano, director of EPA’s clean air markets division, said the transport rule, which is slated to take effect in 2012, will replace the Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). The transport rule, signed on July 6, 2010, includes CAIR requirements, but also achieves emissions reductions concerning the transport of air pollution across state boundaries that are beyond those included in CAIR.

The EPA is proposing one approach and taking comments on two alternatives. All three approaches would cover and set a pollution limit for 31 states and the District of Columbia that have unacceptable SO2 and/or NOx levels according to the EPA. (Click here to see a map of the states affected). The first approach – which is EPA’s preferred approach – allows intrastate trading and limited interstate trading among power plants but requires each state to meet its own emissions control obligations. The second approach allows for trading among power plants within a state. And in the third approach, EPA specifies the allowable emission limit for each power plant and allows some averaging of emission rates.

EPA estimates compliance costs for the industry will be 2.8 billion in 2014. Most of these costs are projected to be spent on scrubbers (Flue Gas Desulfurization (FGD)) and Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) units, and the operation and implementation of all such controls.

To meet the proposed rule, EPA anticipates power plants will operate previously installed control equipment more frequently, use lower sulfur coal, or install pollution control equipment such as low NOX burners, SCR or FGD.

Some individuals in the power industry have raised concerns that the proposed switch to low sulfur coal could be EPA’s disguised advance toward increased natural gas dependence.

During the webinar, Napolitano addressed EPA’s intentions regarding the switch. “Mainly it is coal-fuel switching, not gas. It is only a 1 percent change in coal production.” Napoloitano said EPA’s goal is to have all power plants operating as cleanly as possible in the long run, adding that EPA estimates that in terms of size, 1.2 GW of power plants will be shut down as a result of the transport rule.

To assure rapid compliance with the new emissions control standards, EPA is proposing federal implementation plans (FIPs), for each of the states covered by this rule. A state may choose to develop its own plan to reach the required reductions, replacing its federal plan, and may select which types of sources to control. The Clean Air Act requires states to submit plans to cut down on interstate pollution transport before they submit plans to meet ambient air quality standards. By determining the amount of emissions that upwind states must eliminate in advance of the time that state pollution transport plans are due, EPA plans to enact timely reductions in pollution transport. When downwind states design their plans to meet the air quality standards, they will know how much upwind state control is required. This plan is intended to enable the Clean Air Act to work as planned, helping downwind states to attain standards sooner.

The state budgets for SO2, annual NOX, and ozone season NOX are directly linked to the measurement of each state’s significant contribution and interference with maintenance. EPA’s remedy includes provisions to ensure that all necessary reductions occur in each individual state. EPA poses to allow within-state trading and limited interstate trading to assure that, in each state, the emissions that contribute the most to downwind air quality problems will be eliminated.

CAIR will remain in place until this rule is finalized. The final air transport rule is expected in late spring 2011. More information on the proposed rules and details on how to comment on the proposal are available at http://www.epa.gov/airtransport.

Monday, July 12, 2010

Shale plays: Vaulted treasure for power industry?

July 12, 2010 -

Before joining Power Engineering, I wrote about oil and gas. For the last few years, the hot topic in O&G has been shale plays. Plays like the Barnett, Marcellus, and Haynesville are hotter than Lebron's switch to the Heat. Acquisition prices for such plays are soaring into the billions.

But when it comes to the power industry, I'm learning that shale plays are virtually useless -- at least for now. Like a treasure stored in an impenetrable vault, shale plays have need for much development both on the midstream O&G side, as well as the power operations side. To start with, pipelines to transfer the natural gas from the plays to plants are virtually non-existent. In addition, even if a smooth transport system were developed, coal-fired power plants can't be easily retrofitted to burn gas.

Last week, the American Public Power Association (APPA) released a new natural gas report: Implications of Greater Reliance on Natural Gas for Electricity Generation. Among the findings, Aspen Environmental Group, who conducted the research, uncovered "no instances of coal plant retrofits to natural gas." Not only is switching all coal-fired generation to natural gas impossible due to insufficient natural gas supply, but the entire plant infrastructure would have to be wiped clean.

"It would be more feasible and cost-effective to construct new natural gas units or to dispatch excess capacity at existing natural gas units than to convert a coal plant because of technical and economic factors." -GAO, “Implications of Switching from Coal to Natural Gas,” GAO-08-601R, May 1, 2008. Found at:
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d08601r.pdf

Not only does retrofitting a coal-fired plant to natural gas seem impossible, but such a retrofit would also leave certain areas with insufficient system resources. It would take four to six months to complete all of the retrofits, and that would lead to a number of brownouts or blackouts.

And let's not forget about air permits. While some would say the EPA shows favoritism towards natural gas-fired facilities, at least three air permit issues would still exist:

1) Patriculate matter (PM). If the natural gas-fired unit is larger than the coal-fired unit that it replaced or is in operation even more (which it most likely would be), the particulate emissions may be even higher for the gas unit.

2) The National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for nitrogen dioxide (NO2). This rule implimented a new 1-hour standard for ambient NO2 at 100 parts per billion. The concern is that background ambient NO2 levels would be determined by monitors placed near highways. "This will force urban areas into nonattainment and trigger more stringent permitting requirements for NGCCs," according to the APPA report.

3)CO₂. It's the great air regulation mystery floating around these days (no pun intended). How will CO₂ be regulated? As long as the Clean Air Act regulates CO₂ and Greenhouse Gases (GHGs), Best Available Control Technology (BACT) requirements at power plants will require some type of controls on CO₂ emissions.

Oh, and one more regulation to keep in mind for the future: the regulation of hydrochloric acid (HCI). EPA plans to regulate HCI from smaller combustion units under the Industrial and Commerical Boiler Maximum Available Control Technology (MACT) requirement. EPA has not yet proposed any HCI limit for natural gas-fired utilities, but future compliance obligations should be assumed.

While shale plays may seem like a hidden treasure for the oil and gas industry, it's going to be a long road before these natural gas resources would start to be of value to the power industry. Retrofits for switching from coal to natural gas seem to be out of the question; therefore, it would be years before most plants could/would switch to natural gas-fired. And even still, EPA would have emissions regulations on natural gas-fired plants.

Are shale plays a vaulted treasure that the power industry should leave vaulted, or are they worth all the trouble?