Showing posts with label coal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coal. Show all posts

Monday, July 12, 2010

Shale plays: Vaulted treasure for power industry?

July 12, 2010 -

Before joining Power Engineering, I wrote about oil and gas. For the last few years, the hot topic in O&G has been shale plays. Plays like the Barnett, Marcellus, and Haynesville are hotter than Lebron's switch to the Heat. Acquisition prices for such plays are soaring into the billions.

But when it comes to the power industry, I'm learning that shale plays are virtually useless -- at least for now. Like a treasure stored in an impenetrable vault, shale plays have need for much development both on the midstream O&G side, as well as the power operations side. To start with, pipelines to transfer the natural gas from the plays to plants are virtually non-existent. In addition, even if a smooth transport system were developed, coal-fired power plants can't be easily retrofitted to burn gas.

Last week, the American Public Power Association (APPA) released a new natural gas report: Implications of Greater Reliance on Natural Gas for Electricity Generation. Among the findings, Aspen Environmental Group, who conducted the research, uncovered "no instances of coal plant retrofits to natural gas." Not only is switching all coal-fired generation to natural gas impossible due to insufficient natural gas supply, but the entire plant infrastructure would have to be wiped clean.

"It would be more feasible and cost-effective to construct new natural gas units or to dispatch excess capacity at existing natural gas units than to convert a coal plant because of technical and economic factors." -GAO, “Implications of Switching from Coal to Natural Gas,” GAO-08-601R, May 1, 2008. Found at:
http://www.gao.gov/new.items/d08601r.pdf

Not only does retrofitting a coal-fired plant to natural gas seem impossible, but such a retrofit would also leave certain areas with insufficient system resources. It would take four to six months to complete all of the retrofits, and that would lead to a number of brownouts or blackouts.

And let's not forget about air permits. While some would say the EPA shows favoritism towards natural gas-fired facilities, at least three air permit issues would still exist:

1) Patriculate matter (PM). If the natural gas-fired unit is larger than the coal-fired unit that it replaced or is in operation even more (which it most likely would be), the particulate emissions may be even higher for the gas unit.

2) The National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) for nitrogen dioxide (NO2). This rule implimented a new 1-hour standard for ambient NO2 at 100 parts per billion. The concern is that background ambient NO2 levels would be determined by monitors placed near highways. "This will force urban areas into nonattainment and trigger more stringent permitting requirements for NGCCs," according to the APPA report.

3)CO₂. It's the great air regulation mystery floating around these days (no pun intended). How will CO₂ be regulated? As long as the Clean Air Act regulates CO₂ and Greenhouse Gases (GHGs), Best Available Control Technology (BACT) requirements at power plants will require some type of controls on CO₂ emissions.

Oh, and one more regulation to keep in mind for the future: the regulation of hydrochloric acid (HCI). EPA plans to regulate HCI from smaller combustion units under the Industrial and Commerical Boiler Maximum Available Control Technology (MACT) requirement. EPA has not yet proposed any HCI limit for natural gas-fired utilities, but future compliance obligations should be assumed.

While shale plays may seem like a hidden treasure for the oil and gas industry, it's going to be a long road before these natural gas resources would start to be of value to the power industry. Retrofits for switching from coal to natural gas seem to be out of the question; therefore, it would be years before most plants could/would switch to natural gas-fired. And even still, EPA would have emissions regulations on natural gas-fired plants.

Are shale plays a vaulted treasure that the power industry should leave vaulted, or are they worth all the trouble?

Thursday, July 8, 2010

Questions left unanswered by EPA’s transport rule

July 8, 2010

By now, most people in the power industry have formed an opinion about the transport rule from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) released on July 6. The new rule calls for reductions in sulfur dioxide (SO2) and nitrogen dioxide (NOx) emissions that would cross state lines.

2012? Really?
Industry opinions about the rule vary, but most folks say their biggest worry is meeting the 2012 compliance deadline. In order to cut emissions, plants will have to install new control equipment, switch to low sulfur coal, or use control equipment that they already have installed. But converting to a new type of coal isn’t as simple as ordering a book on Amazon and waiting for it to be delivered. Many companies have contracts with their current coal suppliers that may run until 2014. And if plants decide to go the route of installing new control equipment, such as NOx burners, Selective Catalytic Reduction, or scrubbers (Flue Gas Desulfurization), it will be a frantic race to do so before the 2012 deadline.

Melissa McHenry, spokesperson for American Electric Power (AEP), said one of AEP’s initial concerns is whether 2012 is a firm limit or not.

“You can’t replace a piece of generation that quickly or do a retrofit that quickly,” McHenry said.

What’s My Allowance?
Another question many in the industry are asking is what each state will do with their allocations. EPA has three approaches listed, and each has different strengths and weaknesses. The first approach – which is EPA’s preferred approach – allows intrastate trading and limited interstate trading among power plants but requires each state to meet its own emissions control obligations. The second approach allows for trading among power plants within a state. And in the third approach, EPA specifies the allowable emission limit for each power plant and allows some averaging of emission rates.

“The allowance market in the new rule will be interesting. If you get to the point where you’re just trading within the state, how big are the utilities going to be?” said Block Andrews, strategic environmental solutions associate with Burns & McDonnell.

At the time the court vacated the CAIR in July 2008, the allowance market eliminated the existence of NOx allowances because they were a creation of the CAIR rule. How will EPA refigure the new rule to allow for NOx allowances? It seems the allowance markets may be jostled until these questions are answered.

Do we have the people to make this happen?
One thing’s for certain – there are enough technologies available to implement the new boilers, burners or scrubbers in power plants needed to meet the new EPA guidelines. W. Randall Rawson, President and CEO of the American Boiler Manufacturers Association, wonders if the right people are in place to make the transition.

“It’s a caution as an industry we have to talk about. Times have changed to a certain extent. We don’t have the work force we used to, for a lot of reasons: mergers, retirement, consolidations.”

With that in mind, the question is whether or not the existing equipment can be put to use in a timely manner.

What questions are boggling your mind after the announcement of the new Transport Rule? Leave me a comment to continue this ongoing conversation.