The Up In The Air blog discusses what's floating around concerning EPA emissions rules, and what the power industry is doing to prepare for regulations. You'll also find discussions about Smart Grid and other developments pertinent to the power industry.
Wednesday, January 26, 2011
What is “clean energy,” President Obama?
While to some, Obama’s announcement means the accelerated growth of renewable energy, “clean energy” can be broadly defined. To conservationists, "clean energy" would likely mean 100 percent renewable energy. To others, "clean energy" could mean 100 percent clean coal. My understanding is that President Obama is referring to a combination of all the resources -- renewable energy, nuclear, natural gas, and yes, even clean coal.
“It is a very ambitious goal, and it is also a very vague and broad goal,” said Jeff Davis, co-head of the renewable energy practice at the Mayer Brown law firm.
Currently, the U.S. coal fleet generates roughly half of all electrical output. “There are reports that we’ll still be using the same percentage from coal in 2035. It will just be clean coal,” Davis said. According to the North American Electric Reliability Corporation, coal-fired generation will drop to less than one-third of total generation by 2030 – less than half, but still a sizeable amount.
While the definition of clean coal is unclear, renewable energy is expected to continue to grow in the coming decades. Davis said that the ripening of this “low-hanging fruit” – wind and solar is “key to the continued support of clean energy.”
In order to reach the goal of 80 percent clean energy by 2035, Denise Bode, CEO of the American Wind Energy Association, said renewable energy incentives and policies must reach a place of predictability allowing that “energy sources that will never run out ... instead of keeping renewable energy on a constant one-year footing.”
In December, the U.S. House approved the passage of a tax bill that includes a one-year extension of Section 1603 (Treasury Grant Program). Incentives for renewables typically have been extended one year at a time, leaving renewable energy industries little room to plan long-term projects and investments.
“It’s time to reorient the tax code to predictable policies,” Bode said. “Predictability of the permanent incentives for conventional energy sources is as important as the amounts.”
Davis said that incentives for renewable energy are a must, but the source for funding incentives is questionable. “A large part of the State of the Union address focused on deficits and reducing them, but at the same time the President is talking about providing incentives for clean energy. How do we pay for these incentives?”
The President seemed to signal that energy incentives could come from the reduction of oil subsidies. The oil subsidies vs. renewable energy incentives debate will be an interesting one to watch as it unfolds in the new Congress, given the historic way in which the different sides of the aisle have voted.
According to Obama, clean energy is an “investment that will strengthen our security, protect our planet and create countless new jobs for our people.” If clean energy is defined as renewable energy, then this goal could prove to be lofty. But if clean energy is a mix of clean coal, nuclear, renewable energy and natural gas, then this goal is undoudtedly attainable. The current and proposed U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) emissions control regulations alone are enough to guarantee that all existing coal in 2035 will be "clean."
“It’s advantageous to define the goal broadly in order to achieve it,” Davis said.
While the bar has been set, it will be up to Congress to pass legislation that allows the goal of 80 percent clean energy by 2035 to come to pass.
Wednesday, January 19, 2011
Greenhouse gas regulations and political hijinks
On Dec. 23, 2010, the EPA issued its plan for establishing greenhouse gas pollution standards under the Clean Air Act (CAA) in 2011. This included reference to New Source Performance Standards, which set the level of pollution new facilities may emit and address air pollution from existing facilities.
Holmstead said EPA is incorrect to say that new and modified sources are not yet regulated; “There’s just no standard for what they have to meet. Right now, developers are faced with undergoing a process that gives them a standard, but don’t yet know what the standard is going to be or how they’re going to get there.” This uncertainty, Holmstead said, has caused the construction moratorium.
“EPA is acknowledging that it’s going to be a couple years before people see these new permits.”
However, NSPS are more favorable than the typical EPA permitting processes, Holmstead said, and this could impact the effectiveness of the end product. “This is the big issue that EPA faces: if they do what’s sensible and reasonable for coal-fired power, they might get a 2 to 5 percent reduction in greenhouse gases.
EPA may not be willing to undergo this less strenuous process in order to reduce emissions by a few percentage points, Holmstead said.
Texas, where a federal court has denied the state’s attempts to delay U.S. environmental regulators from imposing regulations on greenhouse gases, will face construction being put on hold for at least a couple years, Holmstead said.
“I’m confident in saying that nobody in Texas will have legitimate authority to build a new project in at least two years, and that would be lightning speed.”
Segal spoke on how EPA regulations could affect political positions, and vice versa. Delays of one to two years in regards to emissions rule-making “could set up an unfortunate collision course with the presidential election.” A three-year delay on EPA’s behalf could allow the Agency to “operate from the position of political hijinks.”
While discussions have been made on how Congress will handle the greenhouse gas regulations, Segal said that Senate’s reaction to the standards will be something to watch. “Harry Reid has been a strong defender of premium renewable energy.” Among the 10 Senate Republicans, 100 percent voted for the last floor vote on a resolution of disapproval for global greenhouse gases. In addition, of the 21 Democrats up for re-election, 10 are from states in which a vote seen as favorable to greenhouse gas regulatory authority “would be a political liability.”
“That doesn’t mean they’re going to vote in favor of an amendment, it just means in 2012, they would have some ‘splainin’ to do if they voted against it,” Segal said.
The Bracewell & Giuliani team also discussed the Jan. 12 EPA announcement to defer biomass from greenhouse gas permitting requirements for three years. Alonso said that because biofuels are not yet under the structure of the CAA, this provides an incentive to build biomass. However, Alonso said that EPA has created a problem for itself.
“They have announced this as a three-year delay, but it’s not clear if this is legal.” Alonso said this policy will likely be challenged “because biomass does emit carbon.”
Tuesday, January 11, 2011
Power industry of 2011, meet environmental regulations
Waiting on regulation announcements and researching what needs to happen at power plants in order to meet standards – these seem to be in the crystal ball for the power markets this year. 2011 has commenced with a focus on greenhouse gas emissions regulations, as the EPA seeks to create a federal standard for greenhouse gases, and lawmakers have protested through at least four different bills to date. These bills seek to thwart greenhouse gas regulations from taking effect for two years.
Meanwhile, Texas and the EPA are involved in the fiercest part of the greenhouse gas regulations spat, as Texas is the only state that has refused to issue a greenhouse gas permit process. EPA filed a brief with the DC Circuit Court of Appeals in Washington on Jan. 6 saying that EPA is the “ultimate supervisor’’ if a state fails to develop or enforce an acceptable plan. Twelve other states continue to work with EPA to develop process guidelines.
On Jan. 7, Texas filed a brief with the Court saying that EPA did not follow procedures to seize control of the state’s permit process and did not provide sufficient notice or open the decision to comment. Texas and the EPA expect a ruling from the Court this week in their case.
Aside from greenhouse gas regulations, a number of other regulations are slated to be proposed or enforced in 2011 (see page 5 of this ICF International study). The North American Electric Reliability Council (NERC) predicts that these four rules could have the greatest impact on electric reliability:
-Clean Water Act Section 316(b), Cooling Water Intake Structures
-Coal Combustion Residuals Disposal regulations
-Clean Air Transport Rule
-Title III of the Clean Air Act; National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) for the electric power industry or Maximum Achievable Control Technology (MACT) Standard
In its 2010 Long-Term Reliability Assessment, NERC stated that the proposed rulemaking adds a degree of uncertainty to future planning of generation capacity needs. When considering the repercussions of these regulations on existing and planned generation capacity over the next 10 years, NERC found that, “Depending on the outcome of any or all of these regulations, the results may accelerate the retirement of some fossil fuel–fired power plants.”
John Moura, technical analyst for NERC, said the timing of several regulations being enacted in a short period of time will have its effect on electric reliability.
“The major driver of concern is going to be the time the industry has to react to these issues,” Moura said.
Recent studies by ICF International, NERC and Credit Suisse estimate anywhere from 10 to 75 GW of coal capacity are at risk for retirement by 2020. Retiring such a large percentage of the fleet could put electric reliability at risk, as could retrofits, Moura said.
“A utility has to take a unit offline to put a scrubber in. That kind of coordination in a condensed period of time can really create some issues both in the adequacy and in the operating reliability.”
2011 – a year for both regulation enforcement and the introduction of new proposals. Generators will seek to comply with new regulations and prepare for future regulations, while attempting to grow the North American electric system into an even more reliable, flawless network.
Wednesday, December 22, 2010
Section 1603 extension marks another renewable energy victory
Shortly before midnight on Dec. 16, the U.S. House approved the passage of a tax bill that includes a one-year extension of the grant program. The program was created by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (Section 1603) to provide commercial solar installations with a cash grant in lieu of the 30 percent solar investment tax credit (ITC). The extension was heralded by groups like the Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA) and the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA).
“It took a year of tireless effort from the entire solar industry and our champions in Congress to get an extension of the 1603 program,” said Rhone Resch, CEO of SEIA.
“The inclusion of renewable energy in the tax bill is a clear indication of strong bipartisan support for the wind industry,” said Denise Bode, CEO of AWEA.
Renewable energy projects that start construction before Dec. 31, 2011 will receive a 30 percent cash grant. Since many renewable energy developers were in a holding pattern until the decision to “extend or not to extend” was made, some projects that were scheduled to start by the end of this year are now being corralled.
Borrego Solar, a developer based in San Diego, Calif., has benefitted from the increasing industry interest in solar investments bolstered by the Treasury Grant Program. Mike Hall, CEO, said the one-year extension is a relatively small victory but will allow projects more time for “baking.”
“I don’t think there will be a lot of projects that will fall out. This guarantees that the solar industry will grow in 2011 and 2012.”
Maria Schnitzer, director of solar services for AWS Truepower, a wind and solar forecasting company, said recently the company has seen continued activity in preconstruction site assessment, although it is “not as strong as in years past for wind.” However, activity in solar forecasting is increasing, she said. As a result of the Treasury Grant Program extension, Schnitzer said she expects to see more business in long term forecasting for the preconstruction phases and operational assessments for projects that are already in the ground.
The extension of the Treasury Grant Program is a victory with a bittersweet ending for most developers, as longer term extensions are needed to provide greater stability to the market.
“We would like to see a permanent commitment to renewable energy policy in the U.S.,” Schnitzer said.
“While the one-year extension is great, we need to find a longer extension,” Hall said.
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
POWER-GEN International keynote address: Regaining industry-wide momentum
Conference and exhibition attendees streamed into the Valencia Ballroom of the Orlando Convention Center the morning of Dec. 14 for the kickoff session of POWER-GEN International 2010. The keynote address, “Regaining Momentum,” included presentations and a Q&A session with Dr. Terry Michalske, director of the Savannah River National Laboratory, Dr. RenĂ© Umlauft, CEO of the renewable energy division for Siemens AG, Susan Tomasky, president of AEP Transmission, and David Fiorelli, president and CEO for the business development group at Tenaska.
With developing countries expected to drive energy demand and global carbon emissions in the upcoming decades, Michalske said nuclear must play a strong role in reducing emissions by 2050. An increasing portion of nuclear growth will be in the development of small modular reactors (SMRs), he said.
“Small modular reactors could be game-changing technology to take us to the new energy future,” Michalske said, asserting the benefits of SMRs: high efficiency, the ability to be monitored remotely, and a long fuel lifetime (up to 30 years).
One of the most important challenges in nuclear is getting through the regulatory approval for a carbon legislation, Michalske said. “It will take a concerted effort between the industry and government in order to move this forward.”
However, in 2009, 3 percent of worldwide generation came from renewable energy. That number is expected to rise to 17 percent by 2030, Siemens AG’s Umlauft said, with much of the increase coming from India and China. Half of renewable growth will come from wind power, 31 percent from solar, 15 percent from biomass, and 4 percent from geothermal and other sources, he said.
Umlauft said manufacturing wind turbines at a national level will create jobs and drive costs down, leading to the proposed jump in wind generation. A 20 to 30 percent reduction of onshore wind costs is expected in the next few years as a result of manufacturing changes.
While storage is often viewed as the “holy grail” of renewable energy development, Umlauft said other tools should be developed first. These tools include the creation of longer transmission lines, prediction methods for wind and solar and Smart Grid innovations.
Speaking on the need for transmission to help power generation companies regain a foothold in the economy, Tomasky of AEP Transmission said in her opening statements, “We are beginning to see the market of transmission as a business for building transmission.”
Transmission needs to be an important issue because of dramatic shifts in the generation profile that have taken place, the necessity to integrate electrically isolated large scale renewables, and the emissions control regulations that will require the retrofitting or retirement of some coal-fired plants, she said.
“Our present system is … ill-equipped to integrate large-scale renewable resources,” Tomasky said. “Renewable resources are often located in areas of the country where there is little or no transmission infrastructure.”
She said that wind generation presents a “chicken and egg issue”: Generators are hesitant to put transmission in place, and transmission is not often pursued until the generation is committed.
“Getting wind into the system requires a much more robust transmission system.”
Tomasky also said that while incentives for renewables may be uncertain, incentives for new technologies are most likely to survive. “Anything we can do to demonstrate to FERC that we’re building a smarter grid is an opportunity for return.”
Fiorelli spoke on the need for developing cleaner coal. Though the long-term effects of shale gas on gas prices are still unknown, it appears that prices and volatility of natural gas will continue to fall, he said. When combined with regulations concerns like the transport rule and rules for mercury, hazardous air pollutants and CO2, producers should begin looking towards clean coal options before being met with the possibility of detrimental outcomes for coal plants.
Tenaska has recently developed two integrated gas combined cycle (IGCC) plants, the Taylorville Energy Center in Taylorville, Ill., and the Trailblazer Energy Center, a PC plant with Fluor carbon capture technology to be located in west Texas.
During the Q&A session, Tenaska’s Fiorelli said productivity in policy-making seems to slow with every new election. “We need people to establish policy, write rules and regulations, and then get out of the way,” Fiorelli said.
Under greenhouse gas regulations, Fiorelli said, first movers could receive bonus allowances to support project economics even under low or moderate carbon price scenarios, adding to the incentives to move toward clean coal.
Monday, December 13, 2010
Hines Energy Complex: combustion turbines, cooling ponds and gators, oh my!
Technical tour attendees visited Progress Energy’s 1912-MW Hines Energy Complex located seven miles outside of Bartow, Fla. on Dec. 13. The complex has four combined cycle units fueled by gas and oil. The first unit began commercial operation in 1999 and subsequent units began operation in 2003, 2005 and 2007.
The construction of the complex was a 15-year project beginning in 1992 that took place on a reclaimed phosphate mining area. Aside from the construction of the four units, the size of the cooling ponds was increased from 722 acres to 1196 acres, and cooling towers were built.
Marty Drango, plant manager, noted that output from all of the turbines is greater during the winter months (by less than 100 MW) because combustion turbines depend on air density. Density is greater during winter months, especially in the humid Florida climate.
The cooling ponds onsite have required a good deal of maintenance, and plant operators estimate that 475,000 pounds of tilapia have been removed from the ponds. Fish are not the only creatures that have made appearances at the Hines Energy Complex. Progress Energy Florida rebuilt 1,500 acres of wildlife habitat on the formerly mined property adjacent to the Hines Energy Complex. In the process of rebuilding the habitat, Hines staff members have seen the return of alligators, bobcats, deer, hogs, eagles, ospreys, spoonbills and turkeys, among other animals. Hines Energy Complex management estimates as many as 2,000 alligators dwell in the cooling ponds.
Friday, December 10, 2010
Treasury Grant Program extension in Senate’s hands
All bets are on now after the Senate proposed a one-year extension of the program under the text of the tax bill introduced on Dec. 9, according to the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA). A cloture vote on the tax bill is scheduled for Dec. 13 at 3 p.m.
Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., led a group of 17 senators and 81 House members in calling for the Treasury's cash grant program to be included in tax legislation. In letters requesting the extension, senators and members of the House urged their leaders to renew the grant program, calling it essential to wind, solar and other renewable energy industries. Some senators said they would have difficulty supporting tax legislation that failed to include the Treasury Grant Program’s extension.
According to the Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA), through February of 2010 the program had already financed over 300 solar projects and created more than 10,000 new jobs. In addition to dealing with the short term problem of the tax credit market, it has also allowed many small- and medium-sized businesses to take advantage of the cash subsidy without having to use the full ITC.
A study by Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory found the wind energy projects that were made possible by the Treasury Grant Program were responsible for more than 55,000 jobs.
"Factories across the country will restart production lines, recall workers and avoid layoffs that would have followed the loss of this key incentive for wind energy, which with consistent policies like this one can generate 20 percent of America's electricity within 20 years," Denise Bode, CEO of the American Wind Energy Association, said in a statement on Dec. 9.