Monday, September 27, 2010

California Enters the Renewables Tug-Of-War

Sept. 27, 2010 -

On Sept. 23, the California Air Resources Board approved regulations requiring utilities to obtain a third of their power from alternative energy sources such as wind, solar and geothermal in 10 years. California now gets nearly 14 percent of its electricity from renewable sources, and the state is pushing utilities to reach a 20-percent-renewable energy standard by next year.

At a time when some legislators are pulling for the developments of renewable energy, a ballot initiative known as Proposition 23 is tugging in the opposite direction. In a state with a 12.4-percent unemployment rate, the debate over whether a renewable energy standard will create or kill jobs has been heated. The tug-of-war for renewables’ future in California – and possibly nationwide – is on full force.

A.B. 32, the 2006-implimented law in question, requires cutting carbon and other greenhouse emissions to 1990 levels by 2020 by mandating power companies to cap their emissions and by slashing carbon in gasoline. Some oil industry leaders said it would necessitate investing millions of dollars to comply, forcing companies to cut jobs and raise the price of gas at the pumps.

On Nov. 2, Californians will vote on Proposition 23, which has been created to suspend the law from going into effect in 2012 until state unemployment falls to 5.5 percent or lower for at least four consecutive quarters. Since that has happened just three times over the last 40 years, the passing of the proposition could effectually kill A.B. 32.

Largely behind the financial support of Proposition 23 are Charles and David Koch, the Kansas billionaires who own the oil company Flint Hills Resources. With their contribution, backers of the proposition have raised $8.2 million, with $7.9 million coming from energy companies outside of California.

The California power industry is stuck in the middle of the debate, with developers unsure whether to move forward full-force in establishing higher percentage renewable portfolios, or to pull back in uncertainty of A.B. 32’s future.

Some large developers continue to push forward. On Wednesday, the California Energy Commission approved plans from BrightSource Energy Inc. to build a 370 MW solar plant in the Mojave Desert.

Still other solar companies are in limbo until the threat of Proposition 23 has been lifted.

Mike Hall, CEO of San Diego-based Borrego Solar, said that power companies approach Borrego for solar consulting or installations because they have an initiative to reduce carbon emissions and develop renewable energy portfolios, and that Proposition 23 brings a degree of uncertainty to these efforts and the power sector at large.

“Everyone is expecting the market to be driven by the renewable portfolio standard and the value of carbon reduction. If we start to bring those things into question, it becomes very unclear where the industry in California goes next.”

Outside of California, Hall said the passing of Proposition 23 could cause reticence toward carbon legislation and renewable portfolio standards.

“I think it would motivate those businesses who have an interest in drilling down those regulations to try harder in other states,” said Hall. “Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, New Jersey and many other states are emerging as solar players as well, and that is largely due to progressive policy.”

Hall said that short-term, Proposition 23 would stall renewable energy growth in California, but long-term it could also have damaging effects on nationwide solar and renewable energy policies.

Skyline Solar is a 2007 start-up solar technology company based out of Mountain View, Calif. Tim Keating, vice president of marketing and field operations, said that while he does not see the passing Proposition 23 to be likely, it could cause California solar companies to focus on overseas exports to countries more welcoming of renewables if it did pass.

“We need a healthy home market,” Keating said. “Until Congress gets a renewable energy bill, we need the states to innovate.”

Keating said the potential passing of Proposition 23 would have more long-term effects, pulling California out of the leadership position in renewables it has established and weakening nationwide renewables legislation.

“Long term, it would back flight the momentum we’re gaining towards a real renewable energy policy.”

For now, California power companies watch carefully to determine their next step, enduring the game of tug-of-war until the outcome of the Nov. 2 Proposition 23 vote gives more clarity.

Friday, September 17, 2010

Coal, Facebook Has Requested You As A Friend

Sept. 17, 2010-

In January, the social media networking giant Facebook announced its plans to build an estimated 5 MW data center in Prineville, Ore. Its crime (according to Greenpeace): Power for the center will be provided by PacifiCorp, which is largely coal-based. As of Sept. 1, Greenpeace had roused 500,000 Facebook users to urge the social media giant to abandon plans, using a children’s storybook-style video to make their point.

Greenpeace says the utility PacifiCorp, which powers the data center, uses 83 percent coal in its energy mix. PacifiCorp spokesman Tom Gauntt said this number is actually 58 percent. Also fueling the Greenpeace flame is the knowledge that energy consumption in data centers can be 30 percent higher than commercial buildings.

So in a world where coal is still “base-load generation king,” is a data center with less coal reliance reasonable?

In order to avoid a potential social networking flop, an alternative for Facebook could be to follow the example of a data center like the Green Data Center at Syracuse University, which became fully operational in April. Through the use of natural gas-fueled turbines, the Green Data Center uses 50 percent less energy and produces fewer greenhouse gases than traditional data centers.

The 12 Hybrid UPS MicroTurbines from Capstone Turbine integrate C65 microturbines with a dual-conversion UPS to provide power for mission-critical loads. In addition to producing electricity for the data center, the turbines supply heat and cooling power to the data center and a nearby building.

Facebook’s proposed data center does boast some energy efficient technologies, however. The evaporative cooling system evaporates water to cool incoming air, proving more energy efficient than traditional chiller systems. While other data facilities often require the equivalent of large central air-conditioners to keep processors from overheating, the Prineville data center one will use the metal equivalent of ceiling fans. The Prineville data center will also utilize Proprietary Uninterruptible Power Supply (UPS) technology, a new, patent-pending UPS system that is proposed to reduce electricity usage by as much as 12 percent.

Still the question remains: While some may “unfriend” Facebook, will Facebook “unfriend”coal? The developments of the Prineville data center would say otherwise.

One more question: Will the power industry “unfriend” this news? Some in the power industry may have the tendency to ignore the media hype regarding Facebook and coal power. But wouldn’t now be the perfect opportunity for the industry to educate the public regarding the need for balanced and mixed power generation? And given the amount of scrutiny the Prineville data center has received, this case may be a landmark in transforming the way the power industry operates its data centers.

Friday, September 10, 2010

Clean Air Transport Rule: What’s a State To Do?

Sept. 10, 2010-

During a webcast on Sept. 10, EPA directors spoke on the topic of “Urgent CAIR: EPA's New Clean Air Transport Rule.” Sam Napolitano, director of EPA’s clean air markets division, said the transport rule, which is slated to take effect in 2012, will replace the Clean Air Interstate Rule (CAIR). The transport rule, signed on July 6, 2010, includes CAIR requirements, but also achieves emissions reductions concerning the transport of air pollution across state boundaries that are beyond those included in CAIR.

The EPA is proposing one approach and taking comments on two alternatives. All three approaches would cover and set a pollution limit for 31 states and the District of Columbia that have unacceptable SO2 and/or NOx levels according to the EPA. (Click here to see a map of the states affected). The first approach – which is EPA’s preferred approach – allows intrastate trading and limited interstate trading among power plants but requires each state to meet its own emissions control obligations. The second approach allows for trading among power plants within a state. And in the third approach, EPA specifies the allowable emission limit for each power plant and allows some averaging of emission rates.

EPA estimates compliance costs for the industry will be 2.8 billion in 2014. Most of these costs are projected to be spent on scrubbers (Flue Gas Desulfurization (FGD)) and Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR) units, and the operation and implementation of all such controls.

To meet the proposed rule, EPA anticipates power plants will operate previously installed control equipment more frequently, use lower sulfur coal, or install pollution control equipment such as low NOX burners, SCR or FGD.

Some individuals in the power industry have raised concerns that the proposed switch to low sulfur coal could be EPA’s disguised advance toward increased natural gas dependence.

During the webinar, Napolitano addressed EPA’s intentions regarding the switch. “Mainly it is coal-fuel switching, not gas. It is only a 1 percent change in coal production.” Napoloitano said EPA’s goal is to have all power plants operating as cleanly as possible in the long run, adding that EPA estimates that in terms of size, 1.2 GW of power plants will be shut down as a result of the transport rule.

To assure rapid compliance with the new emissions control standards, EPA is proposing federal implementation plans (FIPs), for each of the states covered by this rule. A state may choose to develop its own plan to reach the required reductions, replacing its federal plan, and may select which types of sources to control. The Clean Air Act requires states to submit plans to cut down on interstate pollution transport before they submit plans to meet ambient air quality standards. By determining the amount of emissions that upwind states must eliminate in advance of the time that state pollution transport plans are due, EPA plans to enact timely reductions in pollution transport. When downwind states design their plans to meet the air quality standards, they will know how much upwind state control is required. This plan is intended to enable the Clean Air Act to work as planned, helping downwind states to attain standards sooner.

The state budgets for SO2, annual NOX, and ozone season NOX are directly linked to the measurement of each state’s significant contribution and interference with maintenance. EPA’s remedy includes provisions to ensure that all necessary reductions occur in each individual state. EPA poses to allow within-state trading and limited interstate trading to assure that, in each state, the emissions that contribute the most to downwind air quality problems will be eliminated.

CAIR will remain in place until this rule is finalized. The final air transport rule is expected in late spring 2011. More information on the proposed rules and details on how to comment on the proposal are available at http://www.epa.gov/airtransport.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Your Power, Your Company: Going Global

August 25, 2010 -

Is your company looking to expand beyond the U.S. and into international export opportunities? Does PV in Spain interest you? Or perhaps coal-fired power in Russia? The answers to your international expansion questions may be found in Orlando this December.

Each year, Pennwell hosts Power-Gen International, bringing in companies across all sectors of the industry. In its 20th year, Power-Gen (Dec. 14-16 in Orlando) is poised to include 1,200 exhibitors and more than 18,000 attendees. An aspect often overlooked at this massive exhibition is the opportunity to connect with international delegations that provide valuable export opportunities for U.S. companies.

At Power-Gen 2009, delegations from 28 countries were in attendance, with buyers totaling 399 members. The U.S. Commercial Service, an arm of the U.S. Department of Commerce’s International Trade Administration, is responsible for the application process to usher in delegations. Blanche Ziv, director of the U.S. Commercial Service’s International Buyer Program (IBP), said these meetings can eventually lead to construction of power plants overseas.

“It’s a great networking place for all of these meetings,” Ziv said. “The U.S. company doesn’t have to leave their own backyard to meet all of these international buyers.”

The annual application process for all U.S. trade shows to host delegations opens once a year. The open 60-day application period for participation in the 2012 calendar year is expected to open sometime in early September 2010.

IBP considers several criteria to determine whether or not to select a trade show to participate in the program: international interest as determined by IBP’s overseas posts in products and services, export potential of products and services exhibited at the show, logistics of the show to make sure it is occurring in a place that is conducive to international visitors, and the type of incentives the shows offer to U.S. Commercial Service overseas posts.

Once the trade shows have been chosen, delegations are selected, and a directory of delegations is created. IBP conducts a B-to-B matchmaking process in which the show receives a list of the delegations’ services and collects a list of the U.S. businesses that are interested in exporting.

In addition to export opportunities that can arise during these shows for U.S. companies, a door to provide power to countries under the burden of natural disasters is also ajar. Chief Editor for Power Engineering, David Wagman, talks about some of those opportunities in his blog entry Opportunity and Obligation.

Want more information on how to become part of a delegation, or how to connect with delegations?
Click here for a list of 2011 Accepted Shows for IBP Delegations.
Click here for information on how to get involved.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

Everything's Bigger in Texas...Even Power Usage

August 17, 2010-

Yesterday, Texas hit a new power usage record for the third time this month. High temperatures led to 64,805 MW of power usage between 3 p.m. and 4 p.m. "That breaks last week's record of 63,830 MW (Aug. 10) by 975 MW, and last year's record by 1,405 MW, according to the Electric Reliability Council of Texas." - from Chron.com

Thanks to Boone Pickens and the rest of the wind energy producers in Texas, wind energy accounted for about 1 percent of that power usage, with a 680 MW output average during the peak hour. ERCOT has 9,317 MW of installed wind capacity, the highest of any state.

ERCOT assuredly breathed a sigh of relief after no major outages were reported during the peak hour, especially since electric power outages and interruptions cost the U.S. economy about $80 billion annually. But with records continuing to be set, one has to wonder what's going on with Smart Grid developments in Texas.

Smart Grid is essentially a combination of technology and resources to provide balanced generation with demand. During my first week in the power industry, Bill Strohecker, vice president of power sales for ABB, told me the purpose of Smart Grid is to "eliminate inefficiencies in generation, transmission and distribution."

In most cases, power is currently a one-way path. But what if, by charging your electric car, you could actually feed into the grid? Or perhaps you were one of the Texans contributing to the new power usage record yesterday. Let's say it was 3:30 p.m. in Midland, you were at work, and you realized that your thermostat was set to 71 degrees at home and didn't really need it that low. In a Smart Grid situation, you could log in and change your power preferences from your work computer.

Smart Grid opportunities like the aforentioned are popping up around Texas, and the entire nation. A product called the TXU Energy iThermostat is currently installed in 20,000 locations. Last week, TXU Energy announced that it is targeting the installation of 100,000 smart systems in homes and business by the end of 2012, which will include the installation of the iThermostat and the TXU Energy PowerMonitor.

Baltimore Gas and Electric was given the "yes" just yesterday to move forward on its Smart Grid program. These plans are great, but will customers be willing to pay the price?

In March, GE released the results of a smart grid survey of a cross section of 1,000 U.S. consumers. Nearly four of every five Americans (78 percent) familiar with the term Smart Grid said that they believe it would help reduce the number of power outages and restore power more quickly when outages do occur.

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

Molten Salt Reserves (Holy Grail?) Lure Solar Producers

August 10, 2010-

While writing the market update story for the Sept/Oct issue of Renewable Energy World North America, I kept hearing things like:

"Whoever can figure out ways to store the sunlight is going to win. Storage is the game-changer technology." -Buck Martinez, senior director of solar development, Florida Power & Light

Because solar is so flighty (sadly, the sun always goes down at night, unless you're in the Arctic Circle at the right time of year), energy can only be produced during peak hours -- when the sun is shining its glorious beams.

But leave it to a rocket scientist to change that. Terry Murphy studied rocket propulsion at Purdue University, then landed a job at Rocketdyne. During his time there, he studied the Space Station's onboard power system that tracks the sun, manages consumption and stores energy. Now, he is translating his knowledge of the sun by developing a solar power tower technology for SolarReserve, a startup company formed by US Renewables Group, the renewable energy private equity firm. This technology promises to prolong the use of solar energy into the evening hours.

"Murphy says a solar power tower built in the American southwest could dispatch about 500 MWh annually. A 200 MW facility could have a cap ex roughly between $3,000 to $4,000 a kW, installed. That equates to an overall project investment of $600 to $700 million." -Renewable Energy World

It's no wonder this solar thermal development has been coined “the holy grail of renewable energy” by The New York Times. Molten salt reserves store solar power by focusing thousands of mirrors on millions of gallons of liquefied salt. SolarReserve’s technology uses ground-mounted heliostats, heat-concentrating towers, high operating temperatures and storage mechanisms to reflect sunlight. Heliostats reflect sunlight to receivers atop 553-foot towers. There the sunlight transfers heat to molten salt, warming the sodium and potassium mixture to 1,050 degrees Fahrenheit. It is then transferred to a storage tank where it loses no more than 1 degree a day.

“We have the ability to shift power generation. It doesn’t stop when the sun goes down,” Tom Georgis, vice president of development, told me in a phone interview.

So far, SolarReserve has been in a testing stage, but developments are underway for the solar market to determine if this technology will prove to be the holy grail.

SolarReserve's largest projects are:

1) The development of a 150-MW solar farm in the Sonoran Desert east of Palm Springs. The Rice Solar Energy Project will store seven hours’ worth of the sun’s energy and is anticipated to go online in October 2013.

2) A 100-MW solar energy project near the town of Tonopah, Nev., which will break ground at the end of 2010. In January, SolarReserve served a contract with Nevada largest utility, NV Energy, for this project, which marks the first time a U.S. utility has contracted for solar power tower technology utilizing molten salt storage. Potentially, this could be the first commercial installation that will be able to avoid intermittency problems like cloud cover, as well as the ability to provide power after the sun goes down.

Will SolarReserve be able to break through the barriers of nightfall, cloud cover, and such? For the next couple of years, the solar industry will be waiting in expectation to see the results of these two projects. Until then, the holy grail of solar continues to stay just out of reach.

Friday, August 6, 2010

DOE Loan Guarantee May Go To Teachers

August 6, 2010-

This week, the Senate gave final approval to a $26 billion package that will save states from having to lay off thousands of teachers and fund Medicaid. It's expected that the House will give the package its approval next week.

This package hits the renewables market hard, as part of the approved funds will be drawn from a $6 billion Department of Energy fund. This same fund was scavaged last year when the Senate cut $2 billion from it to give to the Cash for Clunkers program. Now, $1.5 billion more will be cut in order to help fund the $26 billion package for teacher salaries and Medicaid. This leaves the DOE fund at $2.5 billion.

I spoke today with Dan Adamson, vice president of government affairs for the Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA). He said solar will most likely be more affected than other renewables by this overturn.

"Solar has more applications for loan guarantees than any technology, so it’s likely to really hit solar in a negative way," Adamson said.

In a letter Adamson sent to senators urging to vote against the cut, he said that taking from the fund would "jeopardize $15 to $20 billion of private investment in pollution-free energy generation and domestic manufacturing."

On a positive note for the solar industry, Adamson said the Treasury Grant Program, which is due to expire at the end of this year, has a good chance of being extended. The Treasury Grant Program is a cash grant that may be taken in lieu of the federal business energy investment tax credit (ITC), providing a 30 percent incentive to property that is part of a qualified facility, fuel cell property, solar property, or small wind property.

"That’s been our top issue in our lobbying from an installer to a developer to a manufacturer because of the support it provides, and it has bi-partisan support. If Congress passes some kind of an energy tax bill, we’ll be able to get the energy grant bill extended."